Can't deploy redemptions on 0.8 Camino on Rinkeby
Closed this issue · 3 comments
I have tried deploying redemptions on Aragon 0.8 Camino with the Agent app. I also deployed 'Vault' as it was missing from the webapp rinkeby build. I used the Aragon-CLI to assist in getting this done.
I ensured that TRANSFER_ROLE permission on Vault and the BURN_ROLE permission on the Token Manager is done.
My organisation contract on rinkeby is 0xEDEd31e0788C8D102dDd1850705654FDe82B17ac or https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/v1adl/ that I am testing and playing around with.
I can add token id for redemption, I can remove token id for redemption. And my redemption is linked to my vault as it is reflected there. But I am getting this Error when I tried to 'Redeem' on the Redemptions app:
Action impossible
The action failed to execute. You may not have the required permissions.
I followed the permissions and settings as in the webapp demo on https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/tryredemptions. Is there some permissions that I'm neglicting.
Hey!
I've noticed that our documentation is not up to date, sorry for that!
We have recently changed redemptions to work only by direct interaction instead of through forwarders. So the REDEEM_ROLE now should be granted to Any account instead of to the Tokens app.
In https://rinkeby.aragon.org/#/tryredemptions we don't have redemptions at the latest version so we will be upgrading there as well.
Thank you for trying it out!
It's my pleasure to try it out. You folks are doing an excellent job and this is a much needed feature. Yes so I changed the REDEEM_ROLE to Any Account and that worked! Does this pose any risk or gaps that any account can redeem tokens, or only token holders?
Thank you!
It does not pose any risk since we require when redeeming tokens that redeemer's balance is at least the amount is trying to redeem.
Having the tokens app forwarding the action was just extra security.