Can we have smoother usage in RequestHandlers as in MediatR?

[jonathanperis]

MessagePipe is just wonderful. His performance is unmatched by competitors today. I used it in an experiment project of mine and the difference in load tests is noticeable.

The only thing that bothered me when I used it was the following: In a scenario of an application using CQRS, the code using MessagePipe is more coupled and repetitive than with MediatR.

I'll give an example: This is a gRPC service using MagicOnion + MessagePipe that I used in my studies:

namespace Cpnucleo.GRPC.Services;

[Authorize]
public class SistemaGrpcService : ServiceBase<ISistemaGrpcService>, ISistemaGrpcService
{
    private readonly IAsyncRequestHandler<CreateSistemaCommand, CreateSistemaResponse> _createSistemaCommand;
    private readonly IAsyncRequestHandler<ListSistemaQuery, ListSistemaResponse> _listSistemaQuery;
    private readonly IAsyncRequestHandler<GetSistemaQuery, GetSistemaResponse> _getSistemaQuery;
    private readonly IAsyncRequestHandler<RemoveSistemaCommand, RemoveSistemaResponse> _removeSistemaCommand;
    private readonly IAsyncRequestHandler<UpdateSistemaCommand, UpdateSistemaResponse> _updateSistemaCommand;

    public SistemaGrpcService(IAsyncRequestHandler<CreateSistemaCommand, CreateSistemaResponse> createSistemaCommand,
                              IAsyncRequestHandler<ListSistemaQuery, ListSistemaResponse> listSistemaQuery,
                              IAsyncRequestHandler<GetSistemaQuery, GetSistemaResponse> getSistemaQuery,
                              IAsyncRequestHandler<RemoveSistemaCommand, RemoveSistemaResponse> removeSistemaCommand,
                              IAsyncRequestHandler<UpdateSistemaCommand, UpdateSistemaResponse> updateSistemaCommand)
    {
        _createSistemaCommand = createSistemaCommand;
        _listSistemaQuery = listSistemaQuery;
        _getSistemaQuery = getSistemaQuery;
        _removeSistemaCommand = removeSistemaCommand;
        _updateSistemaCommand = updateSistemaCommand;
    }

    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> AddAsync(CreateSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _createSistemaCommand.InvokeAsync(command);
    }

    public async UnaryResult<ListSistemaViewModel> AllAsync(ListSistemaQuery query)
    {
        return await _listSistemaQuery.InvokeAsync(query);
    }

    public async UnaryResult<GetSistemaViewModel> GetAsync(GetSistemaQuery query)
    {
        return await _getSistemaQuery.InvokeAsync(query);
    }

    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> RemoveAsync(RemoveSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _removeSistemaCommand.InvokeAsync(command);
    }

    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> UpdateAsync(UpdateSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _updateSistemaCommand.InvokeAsync(command);
    }
}

It works very well, as expected. The only issue in this implementation focused on CQRS is that the modules need to be unique for each request (Commands/Queries and their responses) end up making the implementation very repetitive and verbose.

This is the same gRPC service using MagicOnion + MediatR:

namespace Cpnucleo.GRPC.Services;

[Authorize]
public class SistemaGrpcService : ServiceBase<ISistemaGrpcService>, ISistemaGrpcService
{
    private readonly IMediator _mediator;

    public SistemaGrpcService(IMediator mediator)
    {
        _mediator = mediator;
    }

    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> AddAsync(CreateSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _mediator.Send(command);
    }
     
    public async UnaryResult<ListSistemaViewModel> AllAsync(ListSistemaQuery query)
    {
        return await _mediator.Send(query);
    }
  
    public async UnaryResult<GetSistemaViewModel> GetAsync(GetSistemaQuery query)
    {
        return await _mediator.Send(query);
    }
    
    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> RemoveAsync(RemoveSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _mediator.Send(command);
    }
 
    public async UnaryResult<OperationResult> UpdateAsync(UpdateSistemaCommand command)
    {
        return await _mediator.Send(command);
    }
}

Wouldn't it be possible to have a RequestHandler in MessagePipe that works similarly to how MediatR works for cases like the one I mentioned above?

[sgf]

good question.

[github-actions]

This issue is stale because it has been open 90 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 7 days.

[jonathanperis]

Still valid

[driekus77]

Interesting request / topic.

Depends on the Query / Command type => Handler type => Response type. This should be registered somewhere or through runtime reflection (partly) accomplished.
MediatR does this through tight coupling with DI/IoC and coupling the Request Type hard to the Response type.

Wonder if there will be a solution that will be even fast as current implementation(s).

[driekus77]

See PR #101 and its unit tests!

[github-actions]

This issue is stale because it has been open 180 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 30 days.