hysteresis curve and load line and demagnetization
Opened this issue · 11 comments
Dear all,
I have a question and I will be grateful if anyone answers me.
I run my simulation as same as the tutorial but I want to access Magnetic flux density and Magnetic field that are the output of the solve_femm function but in the output of OUTmag there isn't any solve_femm function and it is included MagFEMM and this function requires 11 input that I don't know how i can get these input to them
can you please someone help me?
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali
rom pyleecan.Classes.MagFEMM import MagFEMM
simu_femm.mag = MagFEMM(
type_BH_stator=0, # 0 to use the material B(H) curve,
# 1 to use linear B(H) curve according to mur_lin,
# 2 to enforce infinite permeability (mur_lin =100000)
type_BH_rotor=0, # 0 to use the material B(H) curve,
# 1 to use linear B(H) curve according to mur_lin,
# 2 to enforce infinite permeability (mur_lin =100000)
file_name = "", # Name of the file to save the FEMM model
is_fast_draw=True, # Speed-up drawing of the machine by using lamination periodicity
is_sliding_band=True, # True to use the symetry of the lamination to draw the machine faster
is_calc_torque_energy=True, # True to calculate torque from integration of energy derivate over rotor elements
T_mag=101, # Permanent magnet temperature to adapt magnet remanent flux density [°C]
is_remove_ventS=False, # True to remove stator ventilation duct
is_remove_ventR=False, # True to remove rotor ventilation duct
)
# Only the magnetic module is defined
simu_femm.elec = None
simu_femm.force = None
simu_femm.struct = None
simu_femm.mag.is_periodicity_a=True
simu_femm.mag.is_periodicity_t=True
simu_femm.mag.nb_worker = 4 # Number of FEMM instances to run at the same time (1 by default)
simu_femm.mag.is_get_meshsolution = True # To get FEA mesh for latter post-procesing
simu_femm.mag.is_save_meshsolution_as_file = True # To save FEA results in a dat file
out_femm = simu_femm.run()
simu_femm.mag.solve_FEMM()
TypeError Traceback (most recent call last)
Cell In[42], line 3
1 import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
2 #plt.plot(out.femm.mag,Ia)
----> 3 simu_femm.mag.solve_FEMM()
4 # out_femm.mag.axes_dict
TypeError: solve_FEMM() missing 11 required positional arguments: 'femm', 'output', 'out_dict', 'FEMM_dict', 'sym', 'Nt', 'angle', 'Is', 'Ir', 'angle_rotor', and 'is_close_femm'
Hello,
solve_FEMM is an internal method of MagFEMM. All the results are available in output.mag after the call to simu.run.
If you want to have access to these results on the mesh, you need to set simu.mag.is_get_meshsolution= True cf https://pyleecan.org/07_tuto_loss.html.
Best regards,
Pierre
Hello,
As you see in my code, I set simu_femm.mag.is_get_meshsolution = True but I don't know how I can access the value of Magnetic flux density and Magnetic field because I want to plot one of them versus the other.
when I write
print(out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[0])
I got this
parent = <class 'pyleecan.Classes.MeshSolution.MeshSolution'> object
type_cell = "triangle"
label = "B"
dimension = 2
unit = ""
field = parent = None
name = "Magnetic Flux Density"
symbol = "B"
components = {'comp_x': <SciDataTool.Classes.DataTime.DataTime object at 0x0000023B68951880>, 'comp_y': <SciDataTool.Classes.DataTime.DataTime object at 0x0000023B68911A00>}
I don't know how I am able to plot Magnetic flux density according Magnetic field
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali
Hello,
I have just updated the MeshSolution tutorial that should help: https://github.com/Eomys/pyleecan/blob/MeshSol/Tutorials/tuto_MeshSolution.ipynb
It's not already on the website (I need to check something in the related PR) but you can have a look on the notebook in the MeshSol branche.
Best regards,
Pierre
Thanks for the quick replies! Can you please give me the exact command that gives the values of variable "B" over time?
I've tried taking the whole dict object of output, but I don't know how to access this variable directly.
Thanks again!
finally, I find the answer for this issue and the command is out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[0].field.components["comp_x"].values
but when I want to plot B versus H, according to this code:
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
B = sqrt((out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[0].field.components["comp_x"].values[:,0])**2 + (out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[0].field.components["comp_y"].values[:,0])**2)
H = sqrt((out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[1].field.components["comp_x"].values[:,0])**2 + (out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[1].field.components["comp_y"].values[:,0])**2)
plt.plot(H,B)
plt.show()
I got this graph:
however, I expect to get something like this
can you help me for finding a solution, please?
Also, I try to plot Bx versus time but I don't understand the title of it, I mean "indice = 0" What is it?
out_femm.mag.meshsolution.solution[0].field.plot_2D_Data("time",component_list=["comp_x"])
also, I tried this code:
group_stator = out_femm.mag.meshsolution.get_group("stator core")
B_s = group_stator.get_field("indice","time","component",label = "B")
H_s = group_stator.get_field("indice","time","component",label = "H")
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
plt.plot(H_s[0,:,0], B_s[0,:,0])
plt.show
but I got this shape
It seems the general shape is the same but something is wrong
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali
Hello Faraz,
For your information Femm does not implement BH curves with hysteresis. If I get it right, you want to look at B(H) over one electrical period at a specific point (node) of the mesh. It seems to me you plot all nodes for first time and matplotlib fills in with segments.
Best regards,
Emile
Hello Emile,
thank you for your answer. Honestly, I am looking for the load line in my motor and I don't know what I should do about it.
do you have any idea about it? and how can I plot it?
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali
Dear all,
I am seeking to obtain the hysteresis curve of my magnets and subsequently plot the load line on them, as demagnetization is a crucial parameter in motor design. When attempting to extract the magnetic induction (B) and magnetic field strength (H) values for a specific magnet (e.g., magnet_rotor_0) from Femm, I obtained an array with dimensions (1000, 336, 2). The left-to-right order represents time, number of nodes, and the values of the x and y axes, respectively. However, when I implemented the following code, I encountered a shape that differed significantly from the expected hysteresis curve. I would greatly appreciate any suggestions or insights on how to proceed.
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
import numpy as np
group_magnets = out_femm.mag.meshsolution.get_group("rotor magnets_0")
B = group_magnets.get_field("time","indice","component",label = "B")
H = group_magnets.get_field("time","indice","component",label = "H")
plt.scatter(H[:,0,1],B[:,0,1])
Hello,
Sorry for the long time to answer, I'm not an expert on this subject so I needed to investigate. In your code is it normal that you plot only the "Y" component (H[:,0,1]) ?
On my side I tried with the following formula:
I defined a linear magnet without B(H) curve so the result should be correct.
Can you check that your magnet material has a B(H) curve defined and that this B(H) curve is set in the corresponding material in FEMM ? Maybe pyleecan handles only B(H) curves for lamination materials and not for magnets. It should not be hard to correct if it is the case.
Best regards,
Pierre
Hello,
Thank you for your answer.
If I check correctly in FEMM there is an option for selecting linear or nonlinear curves for magnet materials (ex. N42).
however, my magnet is N42-SH and I can't find anything in FEMM.
I want to explain something to you, each magnet material has a B(H) which changes with temperature, and each pmsm motor has a load line according to its geometry and when the load line cuts the B(H) curve of the material, this intersection point (in the second area of the system of coordinates) is the operating point.
for avoiding magnetization, this point should be above the knee point of B(H) of the material.
this is the formula of the load line:
B = -mH where m is : m = miu0 * (hm/g)*(Ag/Am)
Am, hm = cross-sectional area and height of magnetization in the permanent magnet;
Ag, g = cross-sectional area and thickness of the air gap.
Best regards,
Faraz Mirali