Distinguish sport=horse_racing from sport=equestrian
Closed this issue · 1 comments
Regarding
sport=horse_racing is not the same as sport=equestrian. A racecourse would be tagged leisure=sports_centre + sport=horse_racing, a horse riding (equestrian) centre would (mostly) be tagged leisure=horse_riding (+ optionally sport=equestrian). Compare
A riding centre is not a racecourse and vice versa.
Therefore, I suggest removing sport=equestrian from the current query for horse racing and just use sport=horse_racing there.
I also wonder why the query doesn't search for relations, only for nodes and ways.
You could add a separate query for just nwr sport=equestrian, but I don't recommend that because you would get everything as POI that has that tag, every single riding arena, shops (examples) and even objects without any feature tag. Do you really want that? Do you want to show every object with a sport tag as a POI, even without a corresponding feature tag? But this is a more general problem with most of your sport queries. I would rather add a query for horse riding centres (tag leisure=horse_riding.
Most of the overpass queries were copied over from OpenPoiMap, and sometimes they are not accurate or up to date, so I'm always happy about suggestions there.
For now I have split up the POI type into two separate ones, horse racing (nwr[sport=horse_racing]) and horse riding ((nwr[sport=equestrian];nwr[leisure=horse_riding];)). You're right that this will also show shops for horse riding equipment, but I cannot think of a good way to exclude them. Personally I think showing a few unfitting POIs is better than missing a few fitting POIs, as it is meant as a way to find places and not as an exclusive and accurate list.