KeePassXC icons wrong
Closed this issue · 21 comments
Icons in KeePassXC are wrong if no database is selected or until you open and close "Help" --> "About" window.
According to keepassxreboot/keepassxc#6299 this is a problem with QGnomePlatform.
What icon theme do you use? I cannot reproduce this issue. Does it happen with any other Qt application?
I use default Adwaita Theme (Fedora Linux 33).
QGnomePlatform Version: qgnomeplatform-0.7.0-2.fc33.x86_64
I can reproduce it by doing the following steps:
- sudo dnf install keepassxc --> (keepassxc-2.6.4-1.fc33.x86_64)
- open keepassxc and don´t open or create a database (clear database history if there is any)
- icons are fully black or gray until "Help" --> "About" Window is openend and closed or a database is selected/openend.
Screen recording:
http://transfer.sh/zSdMz/KeePassXC_icons.mkv
I will ask again, does it happen with any other Qt application?
I have same version of keepassxc and Fedora 34 and I cannot reproduce it. Keepassxc uses a custom theme, I don't really think this is an issue in QGnomePlatform as I cannot think of anything possibly having effect on your issue.
I haven´t seen this problem with any other Qt application.
I would say it´s a problem of KeePassXC itself but they deny. The strange thing is that the icons are turning to the right ones if i click "Help" --> "About".
Maybe Fedora 34 will fix it...
It's interesting it doesn't happen with different platform theme. Can you try to uninstall qgnomeplatform just for a test?
If uninstalled qgnomeplatform now:
All icons are ok then - you can see it here:
http://transfer.sh/IFfoV/KeePassXC_without_qgnomeplatform.mkv
What if you run "keepassxc -style adwaita" while you have QGnomePlatform uninstalled?
That´s interesting. If I run it with "-style Adwaita" everything looks fine!
So what does it mean?
That´s interesting. If I run it with "-style Adwaita" everything looks fine!
So what does it mean?
With QGnomePlatform installed or uninstalled?
QGnomePlatform is uninstalled:
Comparison:
keepassxc vs. keepassxc -style Adwaita while QGnomePlatform uninstalled --> http://transfer.sh/5GceV/comparison.mkv
Hi again,
I´ve discovered that the title-bar (of the "Help -> About" Window) also is missing if QGnomePlatform is installed.
Look here:
QGnomePlatform installed -> Command: keepassxc -> Title Bar is missing:
QGnomePlatform uninstalled -> Command: keepassxc -syle Adwaita -> Title Bar is displayed correctly:
The titlebar (decorations) is missing because QGnomePlatform provides decorations for them. I don't know why it didn't default to basic Qt decorations. However, I still don't have any idea why this issue happens to you, but I'm unable to reproduce it. I would also suggest to install qgnomeplatform back, as it brings better Qt integration into GNOME.
Ok, thanks. I think the problem is that the integrated themes of KeePassXC collide with QGnomePlatform.
Sorry - I´ve recognized another thing:
If I start it with sudo keepassxc (and QGnomePlatform installed) the icons also are correct and the titlebar decorations are here.
sudo keepassxc
QStandardPaths: XDG_RUNTIME_DIR not set, defaulting to '/tmp/runtime-root'
Only the fonts look a little bit different...
Does this help to locate the problem?
Hi, just want to tell that I have the same problem with KeePassXC icons on a freshly installed Fedora 34 Beta.
Hi, just want to tell that I have the same problem with KeePassXC icons on a freshly installed Fedora 34 Beta.
I will try to install clean Fedora 34 into a VM and check what's going on. Thank you for your patience.
I can finally reproduce:
I tested:
- Keepassxc with QGnomePlatform + Adwaita-qt → DOESN'T WORK
- Keepassxc with QGnomePlatform + Breeze → DOESN'T WORK
- Keepassxc with KDE platform theme + Breeze → DOESN'T WORK
- Keepassxc with xcb platform (XWayland) → WORKS!!
This is most definitely not a bug in QGnomePlatform, but looks like a bug in the app itself or Qt Wayland.
Sorry for coming back again:
Is it possible that https://sourceforge.net/p/qt5ct/tickets/86/ could be a solution vor QGnomePlatform too?
Maybe. I will check and try.
The problem is gone now.
I´m not sure why - maybe it´s the new version of adwaita-icon-theme-40.1.1-1.fc34.noarch?
That's because Fedora now forces xcb platform (X11) to be used for keepassxc so it doesn't run natively on Wayland.