Green-Software-Foundation/sci

Whether to include Appendix A in v1.0

Henry-WattTime opened this issue · 10 comments

Should we include the appendix as currently drafted in the first specification release?

Appendix A should be added as the Revision History

Appendix A: Revision History

Currently in dev, Appendix A is additional reporting requirements. (https://github.com/Green-Software-Foundation/software_carbon_intensity/blob/dev/Software_Carbon_Intensity/Appendix_A_Further_Information_on_Reporting_Requirements.md)
I think we should defer the reporting appendix until we have the chance to fully develop the reporting approach, outside of the spec (maybe reclaim the project from the reporting project as a central standards WG project).
Thoughts?

Working group has agreed that the reporting requirements should be removed from Appendix A (and moved to other repo focused on reporting), now appendix A will be used inside the document at the bottom to record versioning.

WG: also remove cast study template

@Henry-WattTime what was the decision on the reporting requirements?

It was to remove this from the specification. (probably also the template?)

#317 - just seen this issue. is there a repo for the reporting standards to go into? keen to have a place to reference it from, even if separated from the standard, as we're actively starting to create reports for software

WG approved moving appendix to reporting project repository. @Sealjay to move.

see Issue #331

@seanmcilroy29 can we close this out?