Scrobbles multiple times when pausing on Elisa
Opened this issue · 5 comments
I use KDE's Elisa player to play my music and rescrobbled to scrobble my local music to last.fm, but every time i pause and then play a song, it'll scrobble the track again.
What min-play-time are you using?
I dont have it set. Is that the issue?
I dont have it set. Is that the issue?
No, I was just wondering whether you had it set to some low value which means the song gets scrobbled again very quickly, but if it's not set it should wait until half the song has played.
Someone else had a similar issue (#78) but that turned out to be a problem with their music player. Is there any chance the same is happening in your case? If not, I'm not quite sure what's going wrong, but I'm happy to figure out what the issue is.
The same is happening to me. I notice this is happening mostly with long songs. If the default minimum scrobble length is like listenbrainz's, (aka half the song or 4 minutes, whichever is shorter), I could in theory:
- Have a song that is eg. 18 minutes long
- I listen for the first 4 minutes, the song is scrobbled
- Pause the song and keep listening from the same point later
- 4 more minutes pass, the song is scrobbled again
I came to this conclusion checking the logs after playing a song then pausing it:
dic 18 00:06:22 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: Found active player Cantata
dic 18 00:06:22 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: ----
dic 18 00:06:22 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: Now playing: abriction - Her kiss in red light (Interstates)
dic 18 00:06:22 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: Status updated on ListenBrainz successfully
dic 18 00:06:23 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: ----
dic 18 00:06:23 fedora rescrobbled[1502]: Player Cantata stopped, looking for a new MPRIS player...
As you can see from the timestamp, immediately after pausing the daemon treats the player as inactive. If I now play the song again, even from the same point, it gets treated as a new play, which then could lead to new scrobbles.
This actually creates another problem with shorter songs if they're paused more than once. If I'm listening to a 2 minute long song, pause at 0:50, resume, pause again at 1:20, resume and finish the song, nothing is scrobbled since consecutive play time never passed one minute.