JohannesBuchner/xars

Torsigma limits

Closed this issue · 6 comments

Rehamm commented

When using UXClumpy model in Xspec I found that the limits of Torsigma is from 0 to 84 but in the paper it is mentioned that it's limit is from 6 to 90. Should I change it?

First, have a look at the top left panel of https://github.com/JohannesBuchner/xars/blob/master/doc/uxclumpy.rst
That geometry corresponds to a completely enshrouded AGN, with little azimuthal gradient.

I don't think it matters if it is 84 or 90, the paper was probably rounding it up. The highest geometry computed has indeed sigma=84°.

Rehamm commented

But what about the min limit because I have some sources fitted with UXClumpy and get so low value of Torsigma 10^-6.

sigma=0 means the cloud population is not there, only the inner ring. This is shown in the right column in https://github.com/JohannesBuchner/xars/blob/master/doc/uxclumpy.rst.

If that is the result, you discovered that in that source the obscurer is a smooth, high-column density structure, and not made of small clumps of intermediate column densities.

Rehamm commented

Thanks a lot for your help.

I would also be happy to look over the paper once it is ready, if you would find that useful. Just send me an email.
Closing this issue for now.

Rehamm commented