MassiveHeights/Black

ScaleMode issue with StageOrientation.PORTRAIT

Closed this issue · 2 comments

Deleted user commented

Recently, I'm using black-engine on a portrait layout page, and I think I found a issue.

The example code is here.

example 1

Black.stage.scaleMode = StageScaleMode.LETTERBOX
Black.stage.setSize(750, 1500)
Black.stage.orientation = StageOrientation.PORTRAIT

When I am using setSize(750, 1500) and StageOrientation.PORTRAIT, black-engine returns following to me:

1

But, I should be:

2

What is the problem? 750x1500 is a size that should fit PORTRAIT layout obviously, but It didn't work as expected.

example 2

As I mentioned in example 1, black-engine seems doing something wrong. I have to use setSize(1500, 750) (swap width and height) in order to make it work.

Black.stage.scaleMode = StageScaleMode.LETTERBOX
Black.stage.setSize(1500, 750)
Black.stage.orientation = StageOrientation.PORTRAIT

It returns the right result:

2

But it shouldn't return the right result. Because 1500x750 is a size that fits LANDSCAPE layout. It didn't work as expected.

Is it an issue?

62316e commented

I dont think its a issue.
But i agree that we need an extra tutorial about multi resolution and stage size modes.

Let me know if you have any suggestions

Deleted user commented

When I want to have a stage which is 750x1500 and is portrait. I have to write:

Black.stage.setSize(1500, 750)
Black.stage.orientation = StageOrientation.PORTRAIT

I think this is violating the mortal intuition.

A better way for portrait layout, maybe:

Black.stage.setSize(750, 1500)
Black.stage.orientation = StageOrientation.PORTRAIT

A better way for landscape layout, maybe:

Black.stage.setSize(1500, 750)
Black.stage.orientation = StageOrientation.LANDSCAPE

What do you make of it?