Change needed

Question

Change needed

Closed this issue 5 months ago · 6 comments

The code needs to be a little more robust.

Speedtest-cli doesn't always connect.

I am using this under Jeff Geerling's internet-pi project. My isp is Verizon 5G Home Internet. The WAN address changes every 15 minutes to an hour.

Jeff's GitHub references a project called internet-monitoring, it also uses speedtest-exporter. It has the same problem.

Another project written in php uses speedtest-cli. It exhibits the same problem.

I think all the calls to speedtest-cli need to be retried if the call fails. 3 to 5 retries should be sufficient.

I am not a python or php programmer or I would fix it.

Thank you for look into this.

Dennis

Answer 1 · 2023-08-17T13:24:35.000Z

The code needs to be a little more robust.

Speedtest-cli doesn't always connect.

I am using this under Jeff Geerling's internet-pi project. My isp is Verizon 5G Home Internet. The WAN address changes every 15 minutes to an hour.

Jeff's GitHub references a project called internet-monitoring, it also uses speedtest-exporter. It has the same problem.

Another project written in php uses speedtest-cli. It exhibits the same problem.

I think all the calls to speedtest-cli need to be retried if the call fails. 3 to 5 retries should be sufficient.

I am not a python or php programmer or I would fix it.

Thank you for look into this.

Dennis

alexjustesen/speedtest-tracker uses php. Same issue.

Answer 2 · 2023-08-19T13:37:45.000Z

I think the WAN ip address might be changing in the process and that is causing the problem. It bounces around a lot on the cube.

Answer 3 · 2023-08-24T23:41:00.000Z

Question: Is the Speedtest-cli code downloaded from Ookla each time just before each execution? Or when the docker is started?

Just looking of similarities with another app showing the same symptoms.

Thanks.

Answer 4 · 2023-08-30T21:23:28.000Z

I have VZ 5G Home Internet via ASK Cube firmware fully patched.

The issues ie: failures are due to the way the exporter handles errors that are returned by speedtest cli.

Speedtest cli occasionally throws errors when on VZ.

I installed the latest speedtest cli from Ookla on a box with Ubuntu 22.04 fully patched for testing. Running it from the command line I see it error occasionally.

I suspect the exporter is not catching the error and retrying the test when speedtest cli is called.

Thank you for your efforts.

Answer 5 · 2023-08-31T11:06:30.000Z

dennis@xxxx:~$ speedtest --progress=no

Speedtest by Ookla

  Server: Verizon - Nashville, TN (id: 30809)
     ISP: Verizon Wireless

Idle Latency: 33.71 ms (jitter: 6.96ms, low: 28.28ms, high: 42.88ms)
Download: 207.42 Mbps (data used: 374.1 MB)
113.92 ms (jitter: 37.85ms, low: 36.66ms, high: 615.84ms)
Upload: 20.35 Mbps (data used: 26.3 MB)
83.73 ms (jitter: 18.81ms, low: 45.79ms, high: 287.21ms)
Packet Loss: 0.0%
Result URL: https://www.speedtest.net/result/c/dc596e4c-1e78-4c2f-9c9d-f9aea781045d
dennis@xxxx:~$ speedtest --progress=no

Speedtest by Ookla

  Server: Verizon - Nashville, TN (id: 30809)
     ISP: Verizon Wireless

Idle Latency: 34.34 ms (jitter: 5.71ms, low: 29.98ms, high: 39.97ms)
Latency: FAILED
[error] Cannot read:

Answer 6 · 2023-09-01T23:17:04.000Z

I have confirmed the issue is with Verizon's Nashville Speedtest server. That is the server that is auto selected. If I specify a different server the issue goes away.

Verizon may have under provisioned the server. A lot of C-Band is coming online in Nashville. Everybody and their brother may be testing their speeds against that server.