Index out of range when using MKtl.find
kisielk opened this issue · 6 comments
kisielk commented
Just installed the modality quark on SC 3.8. Stepping through the tutorial and upon running MKtl.find I get the following error in the console:
HID: found 5 devices.
MIDI Sources:
MIDIEndPoint("16A", "LTC Sync", -1350521786)
MIDIEndPoint("FaderPort", "FaderPort", -1744234616)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 1", -846562422)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 2", -1543287909)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 3", 1382450164)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 4", 1739041593)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 5", 184938043)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 6", -2044030891)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 7", -937346613)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 8", 374286964)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 9", -1036816190)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 10", 1150784474)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 1", 1499504737)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 2", -604032301)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 3", -1885865213)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 4-10", 730710501)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "ETH 1-4", -506382473)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "USB 2", 1183143406)
MIDI Destinations:
MIDIEndPoint("FaderPort", "FaderPort", -1653003416)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 1", -1116144245)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 2", 185365741)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 3", 2072244728)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 4", 1557475687)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 5", 1855480831)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 6", -1651344616)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 7", -172092456)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 8", 323647511)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 9", -1825066537)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 10", 1413141011)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 1", 356405092)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 2", 1005760319)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 3", -242845081)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 4-10", -829524007)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "ETH 1-4", 537248947)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "USB 2", -267914625)
ERROR: Primitive '_ConnectMIDIIn' failed.
Index out of range.
RECEIVER:
class MIDIIn (0x11dc59a00) {
instance variables [19]
name : Symbol 'MIDIIn'
nextclass : instance of Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice (0x11e73fe80, size=19, set=5)
superclass : Symbol 'Object'
subclasses : nil
methods : nil
instVarNames : instance of SymbolArray (0x11dc59b80, size=1, set=2)
classVarNames : instance of SymbolArray (0x11dc59d00, size=21, set=4)
iprototype : instance of Array (0x11dc59c40, size=1, set=2)
cprototype : instance of Array (0x11dc59e80, size=21, set=5)
constNames : nil
constValues : nil
instanceFormat : Integer 0
instanceFlags : Integer 0
classIndex : Integer 350
classFlags : Integer 0
maxSubclassIndex : Integer 350
filenameSymbol : Symbol '/Applications/SuperCollider.app/Contents/Resources/SCClassLibrary/Common/Control/MIDIOut.sc'
charPos : Integer 2982
classVarIndex : Integer 236
}
CALL STACK:
MethodError:reportError 0x11ee56e28
arg this = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Nil:handleError 0x11ee7f008
arg this = nil
arg error = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Thread:handleError 0x11ee47858
arg this = <instance of Thread>
arg error = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Object:throw 0x11ee7ea88
arg this = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Object:primitiveFailed 0x11cd76b58
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
Meta_MIDIIn:connect 0x11fbd6a98
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
arg inport = 16
arg device = <instance of MIDIEndPoint>
var uid = -506382473
var source = nil
ArrayedCollection:do 0x11ee53ca8
arg this = [*18]
arg function = <instance of Function>
var i = 16
Meta_MIDIIn:connectAll 0x11ee44fc8
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
arg verbose = true
Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice:initDevices 0x11ea35e48
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice>
arg force = true
Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice:find 0x11cd76898
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice>
arg post = false
ArrayedCollection:do 0x123049848
arg this = [*3]
arg function = <instance of Function>
var i = 1
Meta_MKtlDevice:find 0x123049378
arg this = <instance of Meta_MKtlDevice>
arg protocols = nil
arg post = false
Meta_MKtl:find 0x123049fd8
arg this = <instance of Meta_MKtl>
arg protocols = nil
Interpreter:interpretPrintCmdLine 0x11f2db928
arg this = <instance of Interpreter>
var res = nil
var func = <instance of Function>
var code = "MKtl.find"
var doc = nil
var ideClass = <instance of Meta_ScIDE>
Process:interpretPrintCmdLine 0x12304ad98
arg this = <instance of Main>
^^ The preceding error dump is for ERROR: Primitive '_ConnectMIDIIn' failed.
Index out of range.
RECEIVER: MIDIIn
adcxyz commented
hi @kisielk,
this is on linux, yes?
- Is there a way to reduce the number of MIDI sources/destinations that the system sees before initializing MIDI? (I am guessing you are not using all of them)
- Do you get the same error when you do this:
MIDIIn.connectAll;
kisielk commented
Oh sorry, forgot to mention. It's on OSX Yosemite.
I'm actually using around half of those MIDI ports (though not necessarily always in SC...). I'm not sure there's a way on the mio10 to disable some ports from being seen by the OS or not. I tried MIDIIin.connectAll and indeed it seems the problem is there.
kisielk commented
Interesting thing is, when I use MIDIIn.connectAll there's still mention of MKtl in the stack trace:
MIDI Sources:
MIDIEndPoint("16A", "LTC Sync", -1350521786)
MIDIEndPoint("FaderPort", "FaderPort", -1744234616)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 1", -846562422)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 2", -1543287909)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 3", 1382450164)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 4", 1739041593)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 5", 184938043)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 6", -2044030891)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 7", -937346613)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 8", 374286964)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 9", -1036816190)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 10", 1150784474)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 1", 1499504737)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 2", -604032301)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 3", -1885865213)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 4-10", 730710501)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "ETH 1-4", -506382473)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "USB 2", 1183143406)
MIDI Destinations:
MIDIEndPoint("FaderPort", "FaderPort", -1653003416)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 1", -1116144245)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 2", 185365741)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 3", 2072244728)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 4", 1557475687)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 5", 1855480831)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 6", -1651344616)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 7", -172092456)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 8", 323647511)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 9", -1825066537)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "DIN 10", 1413141011)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 1", 356405092)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 2", 1005760319)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 3", -242845081)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "HST 4-10", -829524007)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "ETH 1-4", 537248947)
MIDIEndPoint("mio10", "USB 2", -267914625)
ERROR: Primitive '_ConnectMIDIIn' failed.
Index out of range.
RECEIVER:
class MIDIIn (0x113724a00) {
instance variables [19]
name : Symbol 'MIDIIn'
nextclass : instance of Meta_MIDIMKtlDevice (0x11420ae80, size=19, set=5)
superclass : Symbol 'Object'
subclasses : nil
methods : nil
instVarNames : instance of SymbolArray (0x113724b80, size=1, set=2)
classVarNames : instance of SymbolArray (0x113724d00, size=21, set=4)
iprototype : instance of Array (0x113724c40, size=1, set=2)
cprototype : instance of Array (0x113724e80, size=21, set=5)
constNames : nil
constValues : nil
instanceFormat : Integer 0
instanceFlags : Integer 0
classIndex : Integer 350
classFlags : Integer 0
maxSubclassIndex : Integer 350
filenameSymbol : Symbol '/Applications/SuperCollider.app/Contents/Resources/SCClassLibrary/Common/Control/MIDIOut.sc'
charPos : Integer 2982
classVarIndex : Integer 236
}
CALL STACK:
MethodError:reportError 0x118175008
arg this = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Nil:handleError 0x1181750b8
arg this = nil
arg error = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Thread:handleError 0x118174b38
arg this = <instance of Thread>
arg error = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Object:throw 0x118174df8
arg this = <instance of PrimitiveFailedError>
Object:primitiveFailed 0x118175218
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
Meta_MIDIIn:connect 0x1158daa68
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
arg inport = 16
arg device = <instance of MIDIEndPoint>
var uid = -506382473
var source = nil
ArrayedCollection:do 0x118175378
arg this = [*18]
arg function = <instance of Function>
var i = 16
Meta_MIDIIn:connectAll 0x1188404e8
arg this = <instance of Meta_MIDIIn>
arg verbose = true
Interpreter:interpretPrintCmdLine 0x11591f588
arg this = <instance of Interpreter>
var res = nil
var func = <instance of Function>
var code = "MIDIIn.connectAll"
var doc = nil
var ideClass = <instance of Meta_ScIDE>
Process:interpretPrintCmdLine 0x118840598
arg this = <instance of Main>
^^ The preceding error dump is for ERROR: Primitive '_ConnectMIDIIn' failed.
Index out of range.
RECEIVER: MIDIIn
kisielk commented
Ok, last one is a red herring.. I removed the quark and it still fails, so seems this is an SC bug.
adcxyz commented
yes, it seems the mention in MIDIIn class nextClass only comes from alphabetic order of all classes.
can you report it to supercollider/supercollider/issues? and crosslink here?
guesssing - the error happens after the 17th destination,
so maybe the destinations array is inited with size 16 and then fails.
kisielk commented
We managed to track down the problem to there being a hardcoded limit of 16 MIDI devices, see supercollider/supercollider#2492