SemanticMediaWiki/SemanticComments

Officially abandon Semantic Comments?

Closed this issue · 3 comments

@krabina I believe to remember that we talked about this extension in Regensburg in December.

If I understood correctly the CommentStreams extension with it's support for Semantic MediaWiki does exactly what this extension is trying to achieve but in an even better way. Thus SemanticComments developent may be stopped. Note that I am not claiming that it really picked up momentum in the past when looking at the current open issues and that not even a 2.0 was tagged at some point.

yes, it was a bad timing. Currently, CommentStreams can do everything that is required for my usecases and is better maintained. So I don't have any plans to futher support Semantic Comments, I will try to migrate everything where I need this to CommentStreams....

yes, it was a bad timing

Indeed, but sometimes things like that happen.

So I don't have any plans to futher support Semantic Comments, I will try to migrate everything where I need this to CommentStreams....

Since you were the last supporter of this extension when it comes to getting changes in I believe it is best to abandon and inform potential users about this. The code is still available so if some time in the future a developer wants to pick up support for this extension in a serious way it can still be done without having to start from scratch.

Closed per #26