SwiftStudies/OysterKit

Lost identifier annotations in dynamic language generation

Closed this issue · 0 comments

In the dynamic language extension of the STLRIntermediateRepresentation.GrammarRule

fileprivate func rule(from grammar:STLRIntermediateRepresentation, 
                                  inContext context:GenerationContext, 
                                  creating token:Token? = nil, 
                                  annotations: RuleAnnotations)->Rule?

It's a bit of a mess really. There are two code paths one for LHR recursive rules and one for rules that aren't. In both cases if the expression for the grammar rule is just a single element that does generate a token the annotations are stripped from the new identifier (they either propagate into the expression or are lost).

I think the right solution is to make an identifier declaration rule different to others in that it is a rule with the token (the identifier) and the annotations on that declared identifier, but the MATCHER is taken from the expression's rule. You would have to be careful you don't end up with double tokens. If the token is transient then there isn't a problem.

GENERATED EXPRESSION'S RULE HAS A NON-TRANSIENT TOKEN OR ITS OWN ANNOTATIONS

WrappingRule(identifier, identifier annotations).matcher =
identifier(annotations).matcher = sequence(creating expression's token, annotated with the expression's annotations) of a single rule using the expressions matcher but stripped of its annotations and transient

GENERATED EXPRESSION'S RULE HAS A NON-TRANSIENT TOKEN

WrappingRule(identifier, identifier annotations).matcher = Expression's matcher