Invoking Judgement: Can only players in a round vote?
Closed this issue · 1 comments
https://github.com/audiodude/tiny-nomic/blob/master/mutable_rules/201_Turn-alternation.md talks about players being in a round if their player file exists when the round starts. However, it never stipulates that being in a round is a prerequisite to voting (though I believe this is the intention).
Meanwhile, https://github.com/audiodude/tiny-nomic/blob/master/immutable_rules/105_Eligible-voters.md says that every player is an eligible voter and every eligible voter must vote on all rule changes.
By the precedence rules, 105 has a lower number and would mean that everyone in the players directory should be voting on every rule immediately.
I believe that @selfsame is the Judge for this.
My judgement of this issue is that:
- per 201 a round must have the vote of every eligible player to be resolved
- per 105 players which registered after the round's PR may still cast a vote