aws-beam/aws-elixir

AWS.S3.get_object always returns {:error, :timeout} with hackney > 1.18.1

Closed this issue · 5 comments

adonig commented

I recently upgraded hackney from 1.18.1 to 1.19.1 and suddenly calls to AWS.S3.get_object started to return {:error, :timeout}. I tried 1.19.0 and 1.18.2 but still got the same error. When I went back to 1.18.1 everything started to work again. So currently I have to fix my hackney version in mix.exs to 1.18.1 or aws-elixir stops working.

Environment:

elixir 1.15.6-otp-26
erlang 26.1
aws-elixir 0.13.3
Fedora Linux 38

onno-vos-dev commented

I recently had a discussion with a colleague regarding timeouts and the configuration of Hackney in lights of aws_erlang/aws-elixir. Could you try to run with 1.18.2 or 1.19.0 but pass the following as options:

[{:recv_timeout, :timer.seconds(1)}, 
 {:connect_timeout, :undefined},
 {:checkout_timeout, :undefined}
]

I'm curious to see if anything non-obvious related to timeouts changed in recent versions of Hackney.

(I apolagize for the delay in answering you btw!)

  • ❤️1
onno-vos-dev commented

@adonig Did my suggestion fix your issue? If so, can we close this? I can't find anything in hackney which caused this change in behaviour but if my suggestion fixes the issue, perhaps we can close this?

adonig commented

@onno-vos-dev I didn't try it. I just left the version of hackney fixed because it wasn't that big of an issue. If you want, we can close this issue.

grant-zukowski-xumo commented

I'm still seeing this same timeout problem with Hackney "1.20.1".

grant-zukowski-xumo commented

I changed my client to Finch and I wasn't able to reproduce the timeout.