cdot65/pan-os-upgrade

Enhancement: Refactor Script Functions into Dedicated Class Objects for Improved Modularity and Maintainability

Closed this issue · 0 comments

Overview

This enhancement request proposes a significant refactor of our existing script functions into dedicated class objects. The aim is to improve code modularity, maintainability, and scalability by organizing related functionalities into cohesive units. The proposed class objects are as follows:

  • Assurance
  • ConfigurationManager
  • HAManagement
  • UpgradeManager
  • Utilities

Rationale

Currently, our script consists of various standalone functions that, while functional, contribute to a monolithic codebase that can be challenging to maintain and extend. By transitioning these functions into dedicated class objects, we stand to gain several benefits:

Enhanced Modularity: Grouping related functions into classes will make the codebase more organized and navigable. This modularity facilitates easier understanding and modification of the code, especially for new contributors.

Improved Maintainability: With functionalities encapsulated within classes, maintaining the code becomes more straightforward. Updates, bug fixes, and enhancements can be managed more efficiently, with reduced risk of side effects.

Increased Reusability: Class objects allow for the reuse of code across different parts of the project without duplication. This not only reduces the overall code volume but also ensures consistency in functionality.

Scalability: As new requirements emerge, the class-based structure will accommodate additional functionalities with minimal disruption to the existing codebase. This scalability is crucial for adapting to future needs and integrations.

Better Testing: Class objects facilitate unit testing by providing a clear structure for mocking dependencies and isolating test cases. This leads to more robust and reliable code.

Proposed Class Objects:

  • Assurance: To handle snapshots, readiness checks, and diff reports, ensuring system readiness and post-upgrade integrity.
  • ConfigurationManager: To manage configurations, including setting, updating, and retrieving configuration parameters.
  • HAManagement: To oversee High Availability (HA) configurations, status checks, and related operations.
  • UpgradeManager: To orchestrate the upgrade process, from pre-checks to the actual upgrade and verification.
  • Utilities: To provide common utility functions used across various parts of the script, such as logging, version parsing, and XML handling.

Implementation Considerations

  • Each class should be self-contained, with a clear interface and well-defined responsibilities.
  • Where possible, classes should follow the Single Responsibility Principle to ensure that each class addresses a specific aspect of the system.
  • Inter-class dependencies should be minimized and managed through interfaces or dependency injection to maintain loose coupling.

Conclusion

Refactoring our script functions into these dedicated class objects represents a strategic investment in the codebase's future. This reorganization will not only address current maintainability concerns but also lay a solid foundation for future enhancements and expansions. We invite feedback and contributions from all stakeholders as we undertake this significant improvement to our project's structure.