Ed, A.1.1 should not be editing directives
Axel-Naumann opened this issue · 1 comments
Axel-Naumann commented
IIUC, the Reflection TS "inherits" the compat part of Concepts TS, as its editing directives are based on top of those of the Concepts TS. As such, A.1.1. should not modify the text of N4641's A.1.1 but provide its own, just as N4641 does.
NOTE that the current wording mentions "Valid ISO C++ 2017", which should be C++2014.
Possible wording:
Affected subclause: 2.12
Change: New keywords.
Rationale: Required for new features. Thereflexprkeyword is added to introduce meta-data through a reflexpr-specifier.
Effect on original feature: Any ISO C++ programs that used this keyword as identifiers are not valid C++ programs with Reflection.