cwilso/PitchDetect

Thank you, this is awesome!

Opened this issue · 2 comments

theronic commented

I mainly compose through whistling and I've been meaning to make a little whistle detector that will jot down a melody for me so I can develop it further in the browser.

I'd like to use this and build it out. Now that it's a few years down the line, can you comment on the efficacy of your pitch detection approach and if there are other approaches to consider?

Thank you! Never stop making music :)

Pranoy1c commented

Since there's no reply, I would like to share my experience. Unfortunately, I found this to be extremely inaccurate with my Piano at least. Pressing the A4 (440) shows A4 for a tiny millisecond but then jumps around to E and then disappears. Testing others notes don't even show correctly and just jump around. So I would not recommend this.

  • 👎1
Seanitzel commented

@Pranoy1c Well, i honestly dont know what your talking about because i tested it with my voice, a piano, guitar, ukelele and it returned super accurate results every single time.
im using it for my project and it works perfectly.

  • 👍1