dropout may return incorrect results due to improper use of inbounds
yurivish opened this issue · 0 comments
yurivish commented
The dropout!
function applies @inbounds
to a for loop iterating over 1:length(x)
where x
is not guaranteed to have standard indexing. As a consequence the function can return incorrect results and silently access out-of-bounds memory.
Lines 50 to 56 in f1de18b
A concrete example is with OffsetArrays
:
julia> using Knet, OffsetArrays
julia> a = Float64[n for n in 1:21];
julia> o = OffsetArray(a, -10:10);
julia> dropout(o, .5, drop=true)
21-element OffsetArray(::Array{Float64,1}, -10:10) with eltype Float64 with indices -10:10:
0.5071590064611642
0.8322953335779582
0.3388610612978913
0.9177628344956359
0.5919343644328279
0.6557221967728748
0.14356432793391516
0.596784239077887
0.5427223931847711
0.5626176563028811
0.8176537879294099
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
36.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
When an array with nonstandard indexing is passed to dropout
, similar(array)
is passed to dropout!
. similar
for OffsetArray
s returns another OffsetArray
and dropout
access indices 1:10
(valid) and 11:21
(invalid), while leaving uninitialized memory with arbitrary values at indices -10:0
as seen above.