desbma/r128gain

aac louder mp3

Closed this issue · 8 comments

MrGeorgen commented

I play the files with mpd and the tagged aac files are louder than the tagged mp3 files

desbma commented

Can you upload the same track as MP3 and AAC so I can look at it?

MrGeorgen commented

It did not tag the aac file at all. I must have overlooked it because I tagged an directory.
I get the following output:

Unhandled 'AAC' tag format for file 'Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac'
File 'Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac': loudness = SKIPPED, sample peak = SKIPPED
desbma commented

Can you upload that file somewhere, so I can look at it?

desbma commented

Can you test commit ec3a737?

MrGeorgen commented

still the same error

desbma commented

Are you sure your are testing the version from commit above?

File should be properly tagged now, despite your sample file having no tags at all initially:

$ r128gain /tmp/Leona\ Lewis\ -\ Bleeding\ Love\ \(Official\ Video\).aac
Unhandled or missing 'AAC' tag format for file '/tmp/Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac'
Analyzing loudness of file '/tmp/Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac'...
File '/tmp/Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac': loudness = -11.6 LUFS, sample peak = 0.0 dBFS
Tagging file '/tmp/Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love (Official Video).aac'
MrGeorgen commented

you are right, it works. I ran python r128gain in the directory of the git repo. While this uses the local __main.py__, it imported the old r128gain module I had installed. After reinstalling it, it worked. Thanks for your help and fix