ehough/docker-kodi

base image should have kmod and xz-utils for closed-source Nvidia driver installation

ehough opened this issue · 6 comments

ehough commented

In reference to #2, in particular this comment

ehough commented

@mviereck in my testing, you can skip the installation of xz-utils (or xz) as it seems that the NVIDIA installer falls back to an embedded decompressor if xz is missing.

Check out line 747 of https://http.download.nvidia.com/XFree86/Linux-x86_64/415.25/NVIDIA-Linux-x86_64-415.25.run.

  • 👍1
mviereck commented

it seems that the NVIDIA installer falls back to an embedded decompressor if xz is missing.

Indeed, that is interesting. That has not been the case in earlier versions of the installer. If I find out at which point this was included, I can skip xz installation after a version check. Or x11docker just parses the installer for this fallback check (but that might fail if the installer code changes).

I believe that modprobe from kmod should be needless, too. It is important for kernel module creating, but that is skipped in x11docker with --no-nvidia-modprobe and related options. However, the installer fails without it. Maybe providing a dummy modprobe could fool the installer.
Compare:

sh /tmp/NVIDIA-installer.run \
        --accept-license --ui=none --no-questions --no-backup \
        --no-runlevel-check --no-kernel-module --no-kernel-module-source \
        --no-nouveau-check --no-nvidia-modprobe
ehough commented

Maybe providing a dummy modprobe could fool the installer.

I think that might have worked! I did this (essentially):

$ docker run -it --rm debian:stable-slim
# apt-get update && apt-get install wget ca-certificates
# wget "https://http.download.nvidia.com/XFree86/Linux-x86_64/415.25/NVIDIA-Linux-x86_64-415.25.run"
# touch /sbin/modprobe /sbin/rmmod /bin/lsmod /sbin/depmod
# chmod +x /sbin/modprobe /sbin/rmmod /bin/lsmod /sbin/depmod
# sh ./NVIDIA-Linux-x86_64-415.25.run --tmpdir ./tmp2 --accept-license --no-runlevel-check --no-questions --no-backup --ui=none --no-kernel-module --no-kernel-module-source --no-nouveau-check --no-nvidia-modprobe

and it seemed to run without errors. It's a little hacky, but creating 4 dummy files sure beats installing kmod, in my opinion.

Do you think that's something you might want to integrate into x11docker?

  • 👍1
  • 🎉1
mviereck commented

I think that might have worked!

Great! Thank you for checking that out.

Do you think that's something you might want to integrate into x11docker?

Yes, I am already integrating it in a similar way using softlinks to /bin/true that are removed later.

Re: xz
I'll check older driver versions for xz dependency. However, as some NVIDIA cards need older driver versions, this dependency might not be dropped. If there is a statically linked version of xz available for download anywhere, that could be a faster alternative compared to the package managers.

mviereck commented

Success!

Latest release x11docker 5.4.3 does not need xz and kmod anymore for NVIDIA driver installation.
Old driver versions can self-extract, too, not sure why I thought something different. (At least down to 390.48).

ehough commented

@mviereck Super cool! Keep up the great work!

  • 👍1