ethcatherders/EIPIP

Call for Input: Ratify Editors Listed in EIP-1

Closed this issue · 4 comments

Call for Input

Decision

Do we recognize the EIP Editors in EIP-1 as the current set of EIP Editors?

If Affirmed The editor list in EIP-1 (including @g11tech and @xinbenlv) becomes the official list.
If Rejected @g11tech and @xinbenlv are removed from the editor list in EIP-1 and the modified list becomes the official list.
Method Unanimous
Deadline November 19, 2023

Background

@xinbenlv and @g11tech are listed as EIP Editors in EIP-1, but there is some question as to whether they are "EIP Editors" in the EIP-5069 sense. Since this came up on the last EIPIP call, I would like to settle this matter officially.

I am opening this Call for Input as "Unanimous" because this is akin to adding a new editor.

I am in favour of recognizing the current list.


Whether @g11tech and @xinbenlv were originally added as full EIP Editors or not, they've both participated actively in the process and have made excellent contributions in reviewing proposals and in governance.

+1

+1 (voting as an associate)

Since the deadline has elapsed, and all respondents are in favour, @g11tech and @xinbenlv are officially recognized as Editors 🎉