ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP

EIPIP Meeting 72

poojaranjan opened this issue · 7 comments

poojaranjan commented

Date and Time

Jan 11, 2023 at 16:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel

YouTube Live Stream/Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxpLrRIkDlBjDUUrGgF91pQw

Agenda

1. Discuss Open Issues/PRs, and other topics

  • What are the prerequisites for someone to be considered a viable reviewer?
    • Any documentation/resources
    • Process of assigning Peer Reviewer
      for community reference?
  • Should we make the markdown linter required?
  • ethereum/EIPs#5508
  • ethereum/EIPs#5270

2. Discussion continued from earlier meetings

3. EIP Bot

TBD

4. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting.

EIPsInsight.com
Hackmd

5. EIP Editing Office Hour

Recording Meeting 9
Agenda Meeting 10

6. Review action items from earlier meetings

Prev. meeting [notes 71]

Next meeting - Jan 21 or Jan 25 ?

SamWilsn commented
  • 👍2
xinbenlv commented

I might be away from desk today's EIPIP Meeting so putting down some thoughts here.

What are the prerequisites for someone to be considered a viable reviewer?

I think it's great to discuss how could we identify and engage more viable reviewers.
Some thoughts about

  • Any documentation/resources: authors of final EIPs would be a great starting point. Also, [the Author Handbook Draft] (https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/pull/5976/files) proposes authors to consider who they(authors) like to invite as their peer reviewers, and use this list as a curated nomination list, i.e "who are wanted as reviewer". @SamWilsn also kept a list of "who wants to review", we can start with the intersection of these two set.
  • Process of assigning Peer Reviewer for community reference? This is a great question to think, I don't have a good answer to this,. What I do feel we could also do more is to begin with promoting the idea of "peer reviewer" and let more authors and important ecosystem stakeholders step-in to contribute to reviewing. Maybe a periodic recurring author's meetup and/or peer reviewer's meetup would be something worth trying?

ethereum/EIPs#5508

Support. I think it's a great idea to upgrade EIP-Bot to eip-review-bot. Let me know if there is any help you need. @SamWilsn and @Pandapip1

  • 👍1
poojaranjan commented

Moving the meeting to Jan 11, 2023 due to less participation.

SamWilsn commented
poojaranjan commented

Decisions from today's meeting

  1. Add "Peer Reviewer" item to the next meeting for @SamWilsn to explain
  2. Present participants are okay to merge PR-5508
  3. @xinbenlv wants to provide an opportunity to @SamWilsn to discuss PR - 5270 in the next meeting.
  4. Rough consensus is to not make big changes to popularly adopted EIPs as prominent as EIP-20. @lightclients will add comment to the PR-6038 and close.
  5. Bring PR-6269 to the next meeting if still open.
  6. PR-6306 @lightclient is okay with adding execution specs but not the Yellow Paper.
  7. Next meeting - Jan 25 at 16:00 UTC.
  • 👍1
xinbenlv commented

thank you for the effort

  • 👍1
poojaranjan commented

Closing in favor of #208