Xeon Phi 7120p long DAG generation and low hashrate

Question

Xeon Phi 7120p long DAG generation and low hashrate

nikl11 opened this issue 7 years ago · 5 comments

Hello everyone,
about a year ago there was an issue #396 , where a compilation for Xeon Phi coprocessor with Intel compiler on Linux was discussed. After 4 long days I managed to cross-compile all the necessary libraries and the miner itself, and it starts in native mode no problem.

However, when I want to mine ethereum on Minergate, the DAG file generation takes 3 hours, after that the hashrate is only about 1-1.2 MH/s (using 240 threads) and every work is rejected by the server, probably because the miner is 3 hours behind.

In the issue #396 , the hashing speed seemed to be over 15MH/s and there was no mention about the DAG generation issue (citation "The baseline for Xeon Phi 5110P is ~15-16 MHs @ ~160W."). Has anybody tried to run it on xeon phi, or is @mancoast still here to clarify this?

One more note, I cannot use the opencl version, because Intel dropped the support for the newish KNC accelerators unfortunately. Thank you very much.

Answer 1 · 2017-08-07T18:28:59.000Z

Greetings nikl11, The DAG generation took a very long time. My best guess is the process is single threaded. To avoid the delay, mount an NFS share for the k1om and use the host to generate the DAG. The hash rates were misrepresented in the native k1om application outputs. They were closer to 1.5 MH/s, but that is without optimized Hash Algo. There exists opportunity to use the _m512 intrinsic I added to improve performance using 512bit SIMD instructions. ethereum/aleth@ce3f556 If you want to really see the hash-rates go up, try modifying ethereum-cpp with Intel MKL (hint, hint). Thanks, coast

…

On Mon, Aug 7, 2017 at 12:22 PM, nikl11 ***@***.***> wrote: Hello everyone, about a year ago there was an issue #396 , where a compilation for Xeon Phi coprocessor with Intel compiler was discussed. After 4 long days I managed to cross-compile all the necessary libraries and the miner itself, and it starts in native mode no problem. However, when I want to mine ethereum on Minergate, the DAG file generation takes 3 hours, after that the hashrate is only about 1-1.2 MH/s (using 240 threads) and every work is rejected by the server, probably because the miner is 3 hours behind. In the issue #396 , the hashing speed seemed to be over 15MH/s and there was no mention about the DAG generation issue (citation "The baseline for Xeon Phi 5110P is ~15-16 MHs @ ~160W."). Has anybody tried to run it on xeon phi, or is @mancoast still here to clarify this? One more note, I cannot use the opencl version, because Intel dropped the support for the newish KNC accelerators unfortunately. Thank you very much. — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

Answer 2 · 2017-08-07T18:47:46.000Z

Thank you for your answer @mancoast , do you have an idea how much improvement in performance these intrinsics bring? 1.5MHs is unfrotunately super low, so much that it is much more profitable to use a CPU monero miner, which without AES support provides 280H/s. At this moment, mining monero brings $0.5/day and ethereum only $0.1/day, so the performance would have to go up atleast 5x, which is no easy task.

Answer 3 · 2017-10-25T18:08:35.000Z

Greetings, @nikl11 ,

In fact the difference is even a bit higher. Monero hash rate on a 7120 is not 280Hs, but 650H/s (see my lukMiner results), which at today's rates translates to almost $1/day... so the gap to ether is a full 10x.

Of course, that could change if somebody ever were to create a faster ether miner for KNC :-) ... but 10x would be a challenge indeed...

Luk

Answer 4 · 2017-10-25T18:34:26.000Z

The KNC works great for ethereum-cpp as well, I saw about 5X.

Answer 5 · 2018-01-30T09:51:58.000Z

Please reopen on https://github.com/ethereum/cpp-ethereum if issue presists.