georghess/neurad-studio

Hyperparameter not matching

Closed this issue · 2 comments

Crescent-Saturn commented

Thanks for the excellent work!

I just found one hyperparameter was different mentioned at two place in Appendix from the paper:

  1. Appendix A, Table 5, Loss weights:

$\lambda^{rgb} = 5.0$

image

  1. Appendix C.3, fist line:

"We set $\lambda_{rgb} = 1.0$"

image

Therefore, which one is correct? Thank you!

georghess commented

Hi @Crescent-Saturn

Table 5 is for NeuRAD, while Section C (and hence C.3) is about our UniSim reimplementation. We tuned their hyperparameters separately, so they differ between the models.

  • 👍1
Crescent-Saturn commented

Hi @Crescent-Saturn

Table 5 is for NeuRAD, while Section C (and hence C.3) is about our UniSim reimplementation. We tuned their hyperparameters separately, so they differ between the models.

Thank you @georghess.

  • 👍1