freebsd 13.1 issues on THINKPAD x250
Closed this issue · 15 comments
Computer description
THINKPAD X250
Hardware description
The output of
` pciconf -lvb rtsx0 `
`rtsx0@pci0:2:0:0: class=0xff0000 rev=0x01 hdr=0x00 vendor=0x10ec device=0x5227 subvendor=0x17aa subdevice=0x2226
vendor = 'Realtek Semiconductor Co., Ltd.'
device = 'RTS5227 PCI Express Card Reader'
bar [10] = type Memory, range 32, base 0xf1100000, size 4096, enabled`
and
` sysctl dev.rtsx
dev.rtsx.0.write_count: 0
dev.rtsx.0.read_count: 92
dev.rtsx.0.debug_mask: 0
dev.rtsx.0.force_timing: 0
dev.rtsx.0.inversion: 0
dev.rtsx.0.read_only: 1
dev.rtsx.0.timeout_cmd: 1
dev.rtsx.0.timeout_io: 10
dev.rtsx.0.%parent: pci1
dev.rtsx.0.%pnpinfo: vendor=0x10ec device=0x5227 subvendor=0x17aa subdevice=0x2226 class=0xff0000
dev.rtsx.0.%location: slot=0 function=0 dbsf=pci0:2:0:0
dev.rtsx.0.%driver: rtsx
dev.rtsx.0.%desc: 2.1d Realtek RTS5227 PCIe MMC/SD Card Reader
dev.rtsx.%parent: `
FreeBSD version
13.1 BETA1
The output of ` uname -a `
`FreeBSD x250 13.1-BETA1 FreeBSD 13.1-BETA1 #0 releng/13.1-n249974-ad329796bdb: Thu Mar 10 02:30:25 UTC 2022 root@releng3.nyi.freebsd.org:/usr/obj/usr/src/amd64.amd64/sys/GENERIC amd64`
Describe the bug
Trying to mount SDCARD fails and after sleep it comes very slow and gives timeout error
Console messages
The output of `dmesg | egrep "rtsx0|mmc0|mmcsd0" `
`rtsx0: <2.1d Realtek RTS5227 PCIe MMC/SD Card Reader> mem 0xf1100000-0xf1100fff at device 0.0 on pci1
rtsx0: Interrupt card inserted/removed
rtsx0: Card present
rtsx0: A card is detected
mmc0: <MMC/SD bus> on rtsx0
mmcsd0: 62GB <SDHC SD64G 6.0 SN DA7B8E1C MFG 06/2019 by 39 PH> (read-only) at mmc0 50.0MHz/4bit/2048-block
rtsx0: Suspend
rtsx0: Resume
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD0
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD0
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD0
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD0
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD8
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD8
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD8
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD8
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD55
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD55
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD55
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD55
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD1
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD1
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD1
rtsx0: Controller timeout for CMD1
mmc0: No compatible cards found on bus`
now after lsblk it is not visible any more
lsblk
DEVICE MAJ:MIN SIZE TYPE LABEL MOUNT
ada0 0:93 447G GPT - -
<FREE> -:- 1.0M - - -
ada0p1 0:96 100M efi gpt/EFI /boot/efi
ada0p2 0:97 16M ms-reserved gpt/Microsoft%20reserved%20partition -
ada0p3 0:98 300G ms-basic-data gpt/Basic%20data%20partition -
ada0p4 0:99 509M ms-recovery - -
ada0p5 0:100 39G freebsd-ufs - /
ada0p6 0:101 8.0G freebsd-swap - SWAP
ada0p7 0:102 8.0G linux-swap - -
ada0p8 0:103 92G linux-data - -
can you please help me with this
thank
The problem seems to be due to a suspend/resume. I try it on my on Acer Aspire E 15 E5-576-77W6 with
a RTL8411B and is working under 13.1-PRERELEASE. I know this test is not of real help for you. Maybe the suspend/resume must me completed for a RTS5227.
If you have no filesystem mounted on /dev/mmcsd0?? can you try to remove and reinsert the SD card after resume.
Note; your card is in read-only mode - see rtsx(4) in the BUG entry. (if you mount a filesystem, it must be mounted in read-only mode).
I have tried to
1 ) switch the read only on and off
2 ) tried to insert card after resume and remove before suspend
3 ) even if enabled inversion the timeout is gone but the card never mounts
I am lost and cannot use freebsd now as I use the SD CARD as a storage for files across multi boot system
Reinsert card does nothing only a reboot
Did the driver work correctly in a previous version of FreeBSD?
The read-only switch can be set to off?
After a reboot, the filesystem can be mounted? (before any suspend°
I think that the inversion is not needed in your case.
To add the possibility of quick testing:
If you are using the GENERIC kernel, comment for now the line:
#---device rtsx
Rebuild and reinstall kernel:
rm -r /usr/obj/usr/src/amd64.amd64/sys/GENERIC
cd /usr/src
make kernel
and reboot
In a working directory, e.g.:
cd ~
git clone -b master https://github.com/hlh-restart/rtsx
cd rtsx
git patch </tmp/rtsx.txt
make
cp rtsx.ko /boot/kernel
kldload rtsx
and test
Did the driver work correctly in a previous version of FreeBSD?
The read-only switch can be set to off?
After a reboot, the filesystem can be mounted? (before any suspend°
I think that the inversion is not needed in your case.
No actually this is my third trial to move to BSD on my laptop but fails
When I tied 11 and 12 before when 12 was current my laptop was not even come out of sleep after install rtsx
After a fresh boot the volume mounts successfully using ntfs-3g
And stable until a zzz is initiated
To add the possibility of quick testing:
If you are using the GENERIC kernel, comment for now the line:
#---device rtsxRebuild and reinstall kernel:
rm -r /usr/obj/usr/src/amd64.amd64/sys/GENERIC
cd /usr/src
make kernel
and rebootIn a working directory, e.g.:
cd ~
git clone -b master https://github.com/hlh-restart/rtsx
cd rtsx
git patch </tmp/rtsx.txt
make
cp rtsx.ko /boot/kernel
kldload rtsxand test
Ok as soon I get back to my laptop I would happily try that
Thank you for your effort
SOLVED 👍
thank you .. can you please add some sysctl to activate this fix ondemand ?
SOLVED +1 thank you .. can you please add some sysctl to activate this fix ondemand ?
I am confused, I receive this mail:
I have just finished your instrucions
1. now when I boot its detected and i can mount successfully 2. when zzz and resume the delay still there and timeout messages 3. the only differnce is that now i can kldunload and kldload rtsx and no kernel panic any more and it works only after that before I had to rebootthe only issue now is that it delays to resume because of timeout messages and i have to reload rtsx module so the device being detected again
And now you say that it is solved :-o
SOLVED +1 thank you .. can you please add some sysctl to activate this fix ondemand ?
I am confused, I receive this mail:
I have just finished your instrucions
1. now when I boot its detected and i can mount successfully 2. when zzz and resume the delay still there and timeout messages 3. the only differnce is that now i can kldunload and kldload rtsx and no kernel panic any more and it works only after that before I had to rebootthe only issue now is that it delays to resume because of timeout messages and i have to reload rtsx module so the device being detected again
And now you say that it is solved :-o
sorry for that I did make a mistake and loded the modules rtsx instead of kernel rtsx so it was the same but I second looked and found out I was still loading the old ko
My great respect to you
can you please add this code to the main branch and if need it can be disables/enabled by user through sysctl ?
I have no commit right. I will ask someone to push this update but I'm not sure it will be accepted because we are near the release date...
Anyway I will update the github and ask to update the port sysutils/rtsx-kmod which is compatible with 13, 12 and 11.
Happy to be helpful
The update has been committed to stable/13 and releng/13.1.
I think there is another issue but sure its related or not but if the sd card is mounted and the laptop ener sleep mode then X server will crash but if its not it wont crash
i am using automountd .. may be this fix by init the device might causes this issue ? it there something I could do !
thanks
I think there is another issue but sure its related or not but if the sd card is mounted and the laptop enter sleep mode then X server will crash but if its not it wont crash
I am not used to automount...
If you mount the SD card with automount, can you test without automount and mounting the SD card manually.
I did diasbled SDCARD from BIOS and it is not related .. it was DRM KMOD issue and was fixed by updating to drm-devel-kmod
sorry for disturbance.
No problem. Better so!