image-rs/deflate-rs

Remove the flate2 dev-dependency

briansmith opened this issue · 4 comments

flate2 is listed as a dev-dependency. Unfortunately, there's no way to have optional dev-dependencies. flate2 has a lot of dependencies of its own and it would be great to avoid having to download and build those dependencies during out Docker builds.

I understand that the flate2 dev-dependency is used for comparative benchmarks. It would be great if the benchmarks could be moved to a separate crate (e.g. deflate-bench, similar to crypto-bench) so that projects that don't run the benchmarks don't need to pull in flate2.

Sounds reasonable, it was mainly used to verify stuff earlier during development, but it's not really needed anymore.

Would it be enough to move the dependency under a feature (there is already a benchmark feature), or does it need to be removed entirely from the main crate?

What's the status at now? It seems we depend on flate2 in some tests so we couldn't move it to benchmark feature as it is?

Could probably just add a separate feature for it if needed, this library is kind of in maintainance mode at this point anyhow. Also the test could be changed to use miniz_oxide to reduce then number of dev-dependencies.

Changed to use minz_oxide in 7b316c7 which should cut down on dev-dependencies.