Routing-v1 gateway endpoint not returning enough information

Question

Routing-v1 gateway endpoint not returning enough information

aschmahmann opened this issue a year ago · 2 comments

aschmahmann commented a year ago

Checklist

This is a bug report, not a question. Ask questions on discuss.ipfs.io.
I have searched on the issue tracker for my bug.
I am running the latest kubo version or have an issue updating.

Installation method

ipfs-update or dist.ipfs.tech

Version

❯ ipfs version --all
Kubo version: 0.23.0
Repo version: 15
System version: amd64/windows
Golang version: go1.21.1

Config

No response

Description

When running against a node with "ExposeRoutingAPI": true and otherwise default routing I get less data than I can get by querying the underlying routing sources.

Example:

❯ curl -H "Accept: application/x-ndjson" http://127.0.0.1:8080/routing/v1/providers/bafkreifjjcie6lypi6ny7amxnfftagclbuxndqonfipmb64f2km2devei4
{"ID":"12D3KooWFkR8nsG5pzffoAfMzmwBcSakXxnogVa6inRxUbpfN5ua","Schema":"peer"}
{"ID":"12D3KooWMqSiDukubKNKrK7J4PaF3mfNnZFVAd3Lh7qj3Y3e5bcN","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip6/64:ff9b::357:4c09/tcp/4001","/ip4/3.87.76.9/udp/4001/quic","/ip4/3.87.76.9/tcp/4001"],"ID":"QmSaXJRZVyKJNE1tN6hjFtKWSkmfzWWCEzbbnWmu6LJM7h","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/54.237.232.109/tcp/4001","/ip4/54.237.232.109/udp/4001/quic"],"ID":"QmWboxuLjnFvZMErSbuGLZ3VLxZgWKDBX75AV8sZYacQTV","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip6/64:ff9b::36e2:aa17/tcp/4001","/ip4/54.226.170.23/udp/4001/quic","/ip4/54.226.170.23/tcp/4001"],"ID":"QmaB2ZWdnsycNJnCCNSY6QWPfXnuiorKJFQaSdTv7V7e31","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/35.171.88.213/tcp/4001","/ip4/35.171.88.213/udp/4001/quic","/ip6/64:ff9b::23ab:58d5/tcp/4001"],"ID":"Qmc6VMicD94JUeJXGFR75y3J1Da6fQsJSLCoU3wMffDSiK","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/15.204.183.212/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWB6RAWgcmHAP7TGEGK7utV2ZuqSzX1DNjRa97TtJ7139n","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/141.95.66.35/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWNRsVgwCE4jsWS7ZSGjRfkiiSdy5rmtyWvGnCENpevfoZ","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/141.95.66.25/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWL5rvBiZBE9NDWYfbCGSTfQpbScQPxDTfutLbVBjUot9R","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/198.244.201.187/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWC9L4RjPGgqpzBUBkcVpKjJYofCkC5i5QdQftg1LdsFb2","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/15.204.183.214/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWH2m5yQJtQeTbJ3Q4pSuXKgKkrwn282cJrefM5p9bMFEW","Schema":"peer"}
{"ID":"12D3KooWNy2SmgY384B9EHVHdbSkvXEADwxjzd4ejXQqicxWpxxT","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/72.52.65.165/tcp/8888"],"ID":"12D3KooWLirG3i3uZicCBFK4b6oCVwDDc8mZUpuZwGJbLrTLnC7U","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/dns4/elastic.dag.house/tcp/443/wss"],"ID":"QmQzqxhK82kAmKvARFZSkUVS6fo9sySaiogAnx5EnZ6ZmC","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/108.89.91.150/tcp/8888"],"ID":"12D3KooWAEs8Zm3XMaTmk3b1jb9NTJzGE1KYpy4mdPiwiSAo9QJH","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/8888"],"ID":"12D3KooWB6fUFjjLSYcWfM2iAd5ScgknqVP1Dbe6pff4Kqq64CLM","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/dns/f010479.twinquasar.io/tcp/8888"],"ID":"12D3KooWDK1TfLegcZ2Gg3aZaZwiRFvL9pUCSYXKXWVznPBBXypZ","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/76.219.232.45/tcp/24888"],"ID":"12D3KooWSoSgVaUvoguDQZu1doytze9RgnnANwJoiLw7KUcAXq8i","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/163.47.51.218/tcp/28131"],"ID":"12D3KooWEfL19QqRGGLraaAYw1XA3dtDdVRYaHt6jymFxcuQo3Zm","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/195.167.147.43/udp/8888/quic","/ip4/195.167.147.43/tcp/8888"],"ID":"12D3KooWK53GAx2g2UUYfJHHjxDbVLeDgGxNMHXDWeJa5KgMhTD2","Schema":"peer"}
{"ID":"12D3KooWFtNWJWT3UgqeGDiyz41zCuoWQ3BUfGRr32i9hNYFR9dr","Schema":"peer"}
{"Addrs":["/ip4/198.244.178.172/tcp/4001"],"ID":"12D3KooWENiDwDCPnbEQKHHsDnSsE5Y3oLyXnxuyhjcCEBK9TvkU","Schema":"peer"}
{"ID":"12D3KooWNWgNz5QSL2D2YxfKcYo6HyEpFuRnW2fRYewrDmjWJECi","Schema":"peer"}

However, when I query cid.contact (doesn't support streaming):

> curl https://cid.contact/routing/v1/providers/bafkreifjjcie6lypi6ny7amxnfftagclbuxndqonfipmb64f2km2devei4
{"Providers":[{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWM6EzWmykHykwaY5c4Hqb3N5rvQxY5up4bEAzSonSEvHN","Addrs":["/ip4/72.52.65.165/tcp/26101"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgy7IT/MOwcCyUccemaIDnRetumrFaqbLQGv23aPZcRitsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWLirG3i3uZicCBFK4b6oCVwDDc8mZUpuZwGJbLrTLnC7U","Addrs":["/ip4/72.52.65.165/tcp/8888"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"QmQzqxhK82kAmKvARFZSkUVS6fo9sySaiogAnx5EnZ6ZmC","Addrs":["/dns4/elastic.dag.house/tcp/443/wss"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-ipfs-gateway-http","Schema":"unknown","ID":"QmUA9D3H7HeCYsirB3KmPSvZh3dNXMZas6Lwgr4fv1HTTp","Addrs":["/dns4/dag.w3s.link/tcp/443/https"],"Metadata":"oBIA"},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSsaFCtzDJUEhLQYDdwoFtdCMqqfk562UMvccFz12kYxU","Addrs":["/ip4/108.89.91.150/tcp/46717"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgy7IT/MOwcCyUccemaIDnRetumrFaqbLQGv23aPZcRitsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWAEs8Zm3XMaTmk3b1jb9NTJzGE1KYpy4mdPiwiSAo9QJH","Addrs":["/ip4/108.89.91.150/tcp/8888"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAguWQTnuQkhG5DluR57GTeH41uc2tYxYcpH0dV2OJifQRsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWB6fUFjjLSYcWfM2iAd5ScgknqVP1Dbe6pff4Kqq64CLM","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/8888"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgRmpe0ImZ7XR5nFsmFQSus5L3FOgMDDHQXFrfFjhSnidsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgwSNQojyrV3+VNBw89Hybo8kkLlEWoBFSkTYX/QXRSztsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgU91/bZqJFVPw1pvzNqU0oKya8Pv7uPIrCMrT1mHdiQhsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAghNs18Mse+b6mNSN5PGePBwsdQ2Do+3Pp60kkAXAJQBFsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgeTUyRa+sHw1MWcbeYxmoR/Q8nai5Vhgx7pcL1lBULgdsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgdUsiEdxwHkkTkiFM6LnPNckEDLTypN3CK1td+pfdFidsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAggKdxg2zdLBECv8NYZon3FNBh0wRzhttFu4qFBRHPwx9sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4","Addrs":["/ip4/109.199.233.7/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgbIgHHAkYiHkdT/QtqoLBijLws7rtenHgGeeo1hZzPi9sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWBwUERBhJPtZ7hg5N3q1DesvJ67xx9RLdSaStBz9Y6Ny8","Addrs":["/dns4/yablufc.ddns.net/tcp/4567"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgBWeRvg/Htvxnq2hfU7+wurEJ0IC6jkSbVrFklb0crA9sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWBwUERBhJPtZ7hg5N3q1DesvJ67xx9RLdSaStBz9Y6Ny8","Addrs":["/dns4/yablufc.ddns.net/tcp/4567"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgLuoFVB3WZSfjJ5gZpmqHGdRqM6X9hYNqhPCSI5wWWQRsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWHKeaNCnYByQUMS2n5PAZ1KZ9xKXqsb4bhpxVJ6bBJg5V","Addrs":["/dns/f010479.twinquasar.io/tcp/42002"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgLuoFVB3WZSfjJ5gZpmqHGdRqM6X9hYNqhPCSI5wWWQRsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWDK1TfLegcZ2Gg3aZaZwiRFvL9pUCSYXKXWVznPBBXypZ","Addrs":["/dns/f010479.twinquasar.io/tcp/8888"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWHEzPJNmo4shWendFFrxDNttYf8DW4eLC7M2JzuXHC1hE","Addrs":["/ip4/212.6.53.91/tcp/24002"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAg08xTYQgoOmPfipGQm5jJSKgRTmzh7ySGjz+aaxCWkRJsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWHEzPJNmo4shWendFFrxDNttYf8DW4eLC7M2JzuXHC1hE","Addrs":["/ip4/212.6.53.91/tcp/24002"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAg3S+DvUE2jCNv/OPdAMv24tJ0qPKBDWGE7gWVscXeMRZsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWEkQFhSUc17MNC4gimbRYakSSCmDiQwMLhcvToh7bsXbN","Addrs":["/ip4/112.216.168.43/tcp/8999"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgwSNQojyrV3+VNBw89Hybo8kkLlEWoBFSkTYX/QXRSztsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9A=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSXEgHSetvDyB6S9xYwKs8ruYNkimUiSrjMvQ7ZkrZWQW","Addrs":["/ip4/213.109.236.18/tcp/0"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgqxzwCSQ/OORzI3kbZQGMntmLqxuhZNdGPscYy5eK2jNsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSXEgHSetvDyB6S9xYwKs8ruYNkimUiSrjMvQ7ZkrZWQW","Addrs":["/ip4/213.109.236.18/tcp/0"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgby7kMrbNGejluYLzuW2/hkONmoe5rAi+bZOXr1XTFCFsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSXEgHSetvDyB6S9xYwKs8ruYNkimUiSrjMvQ7ZkrZWQW","Addrs":["/ip4/213.109.236.18/tcp/0"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgy7IT/MOwcCyUccemaIDnRetumrFaqbLQGv23aPZcRitsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSXEgHSetvDyB6S9xYwKs8ruYNkimUiSrjMvQ7ZkrZWQW","Addrs":["/ip4/213.109.236.18/tcp/0"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgNjnhqwnJ9ypZ691taYzXOAxQnaOjeVGZfcQNsK7U1x5sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWGiYSQSRfyifPkny5n82xrue7ZZBon3M2cVJxeash9doC","Addrs":["/ip4/136.144.57.65/tcp/10211"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgjvagTFNDUD+Ae2U7ofCe1qhM0PLk+EebdWHJtrhz4RdsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9A=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWBwUERBhJPtZ7hg5N3q1DesvJ67xx9RLdSaStBz9Y6Ny8","Addrs":["/dns4/yablufc.ddns.net/tcp/4567"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAg3S+DvUE2jCNv/OPdAMv24tJ0qPKBDWGE7gWVscXeMRZsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWPNbkEgjdBNeaCGpsgCrPRETe4uBZf1ShFXStobdN18ys","Addrs":["/ip4/76.219.232.45/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgVFs7U2Qg25T0HbDBoD1m0RpzwK8EzGTpZK5oSJDKmTZsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWSoSgVaUvoguDQZu1doytze9RgnnANwJoiLw7KUcAXq8i","Addrs":["/ip4/76.219.232.45/tcp/24888"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWPNbkEgjdBNeaCGpsgCrPRETe4uBZf1ShFXStobdN18ys","Addrs":["/ip4/76.219.232.45/tcp/24001"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgRAscqIBZNdq78Rp2Fudc24hBJ1TMIbb7HhA95rjxgxFsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWM6EzWmykHykwaY5c4Hqb3N5rvQxY5up4bEAzSonSEvHN","Addrs":["/ip4/72.52.65.165/tcp/26101"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgby7kMrbNGejluYLzuW2/hkONmoe5rAi+bZOXr1XTFCFsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWSsaFCtzDJUEhLQYDdwoFtdCMqqfk562UMvccFz12kYxU","Addrs":["/ip4/108.89.91.150/tcp/46717"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgby7kMrbNGejluYLzuW2/hkONmoe5rAi+bZOXr1XTFCFsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWHcDGQUa1NeaTHcV68XQBJxCcRAty2sN8pWcj8xVSCQsy","Addrs":["/ip4/163.47.51.218/tcp/28031"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAg25Tsl3gNI9NWDGMoNxPpn7OZg1XyrnLTPVxRKkIMcA9sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWEfL19QqRGGLraaAYw1XA3dtDdVRYaHt6jymFxcuQo3Zm","Addrs":["/ip4/163.47.51.218/tcp/28131"],"Metadata":"gBI="},{"Protocol":"transport-graphsync-filecoinv1","Schema":"graphsync-filecoinv1","ID":"12D3KooWDtiA9w5c37MnFpGWr2M12m8neoUqDroHEMsJVuf3ELi7","Addrs":["/ip4/195.167.147.43/tcp/9999"],"Metadata":"kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAg25Tsl3gNI9NWDGMoNxPpn7OZg1XyrnLTPVxRKkIMcA9sVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q=="},{"Protocol":"transport-bitswap","Schema":"bitswap","ID":"12D3KooWK53GAx2g2UUYfJHHjxDbVLeDgGxNMHXDWeJa5KgMhTD2","Addrs":["/ip4/195.167.147.43/udp/8888/quic","/ip4/195.167.147.43/tcp/8888"],"Metadata":"gBI="}]}

# This is a mess so, some basics
$provs = curl https://cid.contact/routing/v1/providers/bafkreifjjcie6lypi6ny7amxnfftagclbuxndqonfipmb64f2km2devei4
❯ $provs | jq -r '[.Providers[] | .["ID"]] | unique | sort'
[
  "12D3KooWAEs8Zm3XMaTmk3b1jb9NTJzGE1KYpy4mdPiwiSAo9QJH",
  "12D3KooWB6fUFjjLSYcWfM2iAd5ScgknqVP1Dbe6pff4Kqq64CLM",
  "12D3KooWBwUERBhJPtZ7hg5N3q1DesvJ67xx9RLdSaStBz9Y6Ny8",
  "12D3KooWDK1TfLegcZ2Gg3aZaZwiRFvL9pUCSYXKXWVznPBBXypZ",
  "12D3KooWDtiA9w5c37MnFpGWr2M12m8neoUqDroHEMsJVuf3ELi7",
  "12D3KooWEfL19QqRGGLraaAYw1XA3dtDdVRYaHt6jymFxcuQo3Zm",
  "12D3KooWEkQFhSUc17MNC4gimbRYakSSCmDiQwMLhcvToh7bsXbN",
  "12D3KooWGiYSQSRfyifPkny5n82xrue7ZZBon3M2cVJxeash9doC",
  "12D3KooWHEzPJNmo4shWendFFrxDNttYf8DW4eLC7M2JzuXHC1hE",
  "12D3KooWHKeaNCnYByQUMS2n5PAZ1KZ9xKXqsb4bhpxVJ6bBJg5V",
  "12D3KooWHcDGQUa1NeaTHcV68XQBJxCcRAty2sN8pWcj8xVSCQsy",
  "12D3KooWK53GAx2g2UUYfJHHjxDbVLeDgGxNMHXDWeJa5KgMhTD2",
  "12D3KooWLirG3i3uZicCBFK4b6oCVwDDc8mZUpuZwGJbLrTLnC7U",
  "12D3KooWM6EzWmykHykwaY5c4Hqb3N5rvQxY5up4bEAzSonSEvHN",
  "12D3KooWNfaZqw9DD7mTkyfzudR3vFT9HcdBnaSNLGcuaANMFTh4",
  "12D3KooWPNbkEgjdBNeaCGpsgCrPRETe4uBZf1ShFXStobdN18ys",
  "12D3KooWSXEgHSetvDyB6S9xYwKs8ruYNkimUiSrjMvQ7ZkrZWQW",
  "12D3KooWSoSgVaUvoguDQZu1doytze9RgnnANwJoiLw7KUcAXq8i",
  "12D3KooWSsaFCtzDJUEhLQYDdwoFtdCMqqfk562UMvccFz12kYxU",
  "QmQzqxhK82kAmKvARFZSkUVS6fo9sySaiogAnx5EnZ6ZmC",
  "QmUA9D3H7HeCYsirB3KmPSvZh3dNXMZas6Lwgr4fv1HTTp"
]

Note: Some peers like QmUA9D3H7HeCYsirB3KmPSvZh3dNXMZas6Lwgr4fv1HTTp and 12D3KooWEkQFhSUc17MNC4gimbRYakSSCmDiQwMLhcvToh7bsXbN are missing. These peers have return data like:

Protocol : transport-ipfs-gateway-http
Schema   : unknown
ID       : QmUA9D3H7HeCYsirB3KmPSvZh3dNXMZas6Lwgr4fv1HTTp
Addrs    : {/dns4/dag.w3s.link/tcp/443/https}
Metadata : oBIA

Protocol : transport-graphsync-filecoinv1
Schema   : graphsync-filecoinv1
ID       : 12D3KooWSsaFCtzDJUEhLQYDdwoFtdCMqqfk562UMvccFz12kYxU
Addrs    : {/ip4/108.89.91.150/tcp/46717}
Metadata : kBKjaFBpZWNlQ0lE2CpYKAABgeIDkiAgy7IT/MOwcCyUccemaIDnRetumrFaqbLQGv23aPZcRitsVmVyaWZpZWREZWFs9W1GYXN0UmV0cmlldmFs9Q==

Which seems to indicate that some less familiar schemas that might not be helpful to kubo itself (e.g. anything but peer and bitswap) might be getting dropped. This is likely not what's intended when the API is used directly vs when it's been processed inside kubo for its use (i.e. internally kubo should of course drop the routing records it has no use for).

Note: cid.contact may also have some bugs here in both emitting legacy record types and not handling metadata correctly.

Answer 1 · 2023-11-28T18:10:28.000Z

2023-11-28 conversation: going to get this working in someguy first, then can port it over here to Kubo.

Answer 2 · 2024-02-08T19:51:55.000Z

Quick status update:

If someone needs a pass-through that does no filtering, that is solved by https://github.com/ipfs-shipyard/someguy, which is deployed at https://delegated-ipfs.dev/routing/v1/ and returns DHT+IPNI(cid.contact) results, and supports streaming responses:

$ curl -H "Accept: application/x-ndjson" https://delegated-ipfs.dev/routing/v1/providers/bafybeigdyrzt5sfp7udm7hu76uh7y26nf3efuylqabf3oclgtqy55fbzdi -s | jq

Due to this, this issue is now a lower priority, and there is no ETA when/if Kubo will do the same. I've opened #10337 with a proposal to close this and say filtering is a feature of Kubo. We can always revisit in the future.