Random error message "Root resource was present, but now absent" on virtual repository creation
jmvitali opened this issue · 10 comments
jmvitali commented
Describe the bug
Random error message "Root resource was present, but now absent" on virtual repository creation.
Requirements for and issue
- Random error message "Root resource was present, but now absent" on virtual repository creation
- A fully functioning terraform snippet that can be copy&pasted (no outside files or ENV vars unless that's part of the issue).
resource "artifactory_virtual_docker_repository" "create_virtual_repo" {
artifactory_requests_can_retrieve_remote_artifacts = false
default_deployment_repo = "ipp-generic-prod-ipp-nce-docker-prod-toa-nce"
description = "Description"
id = (known after apply)
includes_pattern = "**/*"
key = "ipp-generic-prod-ipp-nce-docker-prod-toa"
notes = "managed by terraform"
package_type = (known after apply)
project_environments = (known after apply)
project_key = "default"
repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
repositories = [
"ipp-generic-prod-ipp-nce-docker-prod-toa-nce",
]
resolve_docker_tags_by_timestamp = false
}
- Your version of artifactory : 8.9.1
- Your version of terraform : 1.6.5
Expected behavior
Virtual repository creation each time.
Thanks a lot in advance for your help.
Best Regards,
JM
alexhung commented
@jmvitali Thanks for the report. Can you share the output of the terraform plan or terraform apply command? i.e. The entire output of the error message.
jmvitali commented
Hello @alexhung,
Thanks to take care on that request.
We reproduce this issue this morning.
Please find the output of the related terraform apply command:
Terraform will perform the following actions:
# restapi_object.add_repo_properties will be created
+ resource "restapi_object" "add_repo_properties" {
+ api_data = (known after apply)
+ api_response = (known after apply)
+ create_response = (known after apply)
+ data = jsonencode(
{
+ cleanupAqlLimit = "100000"
+ cleanupDays = "1095"
+ cleanupDryrun = "false"
+ cleanupStrategy = "1"
+ iz = "arti"
+ repoQuota = "53687091200"
}
)
+ id = (known after apply)
+ object_id = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce_set_properties"
+ path = "/properties?repository=testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
}
# time_sleep.wait_5_seconds will be created
+ resource "time_sleep" "wait_5_seconds" {
+ create_duration = "5s"
+ id = (known after apply)
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository will be created
+ resource "artifactory_remote_docker_repository" "create_remote_repository" {
+ allow_any_host_auth = false
+ assumed_offline_period_secs = 300
+ blacked_out = false
+ block_mismatching_mime_types = true
+ block_pushing_schema1 = (known after apply)
+ bypass_head_requests = false
+ cdn_redirect = false
+ client_tls_certificate = (known after apply)
+ description = "description"
+ disable_proxy = false
+ disable_url_normalization = false
+ download_direct = false
+ enable_cookie_management = false
+ enable_token_authentication = (known after apply)
+ external_dependencies_enabled = false
+ hard_fail = false
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote"
+ list_remote_folder_items = true
+ metadata_retrieval_timeout_secs = 60
+ missed_cache_period_seconds = 1800
+ notes = "ticket=ControlTower"
+ offline = false
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ password = (sensitive value)
+ priority_resolution = false
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ retrieval_cache_period_seconds = 7200
+ share_configuration = (known after apply)
+ socket_timeout_millis = 15000
+ store_artifacts_locally = true
+ synchronize_properties = false
+ unused_artifacts_cleanup_period_hours = 48
+ url = "https://*******/artifactory/api/docker/testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
+ username = "app-artifactory"
+ xray_index = false
+ content_synchronisation {
+ enabled = true
+ properties_enabled = true
+ source_origin_absence_detection = true
+ statistics_enabled = false
}
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo will be created
+ resource "artifactory_virtual_docker_repository" "create_virtual_repo" {
+ artifactory_requests_can_retrieve_remote_artifacts = false
+ description = "Description"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti"
+ notes = "managed by terraform"
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ repositories = [
+ "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote",
]
+ resolve_docker_tags_by_timestamp = false
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds will be created
+ resource "time_sleep" "wait_5_seconds" {
+ create_duration = "5s"
+ id = (known after apply)
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository will be created
+ resource "artifactory_remote_docker_repository" "create_remote_repository" {
+ allow_any_host_auth = false
+ assumed_offline_period_secs = 300
+ blacked_out = false
+ block_mismatching_mime_types = true
+ block_pushing_schema1 = (known after apply)
+ bypass_head_requests = false
+ cdn_redirect = false
+ client_tls_certificate = (known after apply)
+ description = "description"
+ disable_proxy = false
+ disable_url_normalization = false
+ download_direct = false
+ enable_cookie_management = false
+ enable_token_authentication = (known after apply)
+ external_dependencies_enabled = false
+ hard_fail = false
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote"
+ list_remote_folder_items = true
+ metadata_retrieval_timeout_secs = 60
+ missed_cache_period_seconds = 1800
+ notes = "ticket=ControlTower"
+ offline = false
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ password = (sensitive value)
+ priority_resolution = false
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ retrieval_cache_period_seconds = 7200
+ share_configuration = (known after apply)
+ socket_timeout_millis = 15000
+ store_artifacts_locally = true
+ synchronize_properties = false
+ unused_artifacts_cleanup_period_hours = 48
+ url = "https://****/artifactory/api/docker/testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
+ username = "app-artifactory"
+ xray_index = false
+ content_synchronisation {
+ enabled = true
+ properties_enabled = true
+ source_origin_absence_detection = true
+ statistics_enabled = false
}
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo will be created
+ resource "artifactory_virtual_docker_repository" "create_virtual_repo" {
+ artifactory_requests_can_retrieve_remote_artifacts = false
+ description = "Description"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti"
+ notes = "managed by terraform"
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ repositories = [
+ "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote",
]
+ resolve_docker_tags_by_timestamp = false
}
# module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds will be created
+ resource "time_sleep" "wait_5_seconds" {
+ create_duration = "5s"
+ id = (known after apply)
}
# module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository.create_local_repository will be created
+ resource "artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository" "create_local_repository" {
+ api_version = (known after apply)
+ blacked_out = false
+ block_pushing_schema1 = (known after apply)
+ cdn_redirect = false
+ description = "description"
+ excludes_pattern = (known after apply)
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
+ max_unique_tags = 0
+ notes = "ticket=ControlTower"
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ priority_resolution = false
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ xray_index = false
}
# module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo will be created
+ resource "artifactory_virtual_docker_repository" "create_virtual_repo" {
+ artifactory_requests_can_retrieve_remote_artifacts = false
+ default_deployment_repo = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
+ description = "Description"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ includes_pattern = "**/*"
+ key = "testremote-docker-release-arti"
+ notes = "managed by terraform"
+ package_type = (known after apply)
+ project_environments = (known after apply)
+ project_key = "default"
+ repo_layout_ref = "simple-default"
+ repositories = [
+ "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce",
]
+ resolve_docker_tags_by_timestamp = false
}
# module.create-repo-docker.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds will be created
+ resource "time_sleep" "wait_5_seconds" {
+ create_duration = "5s"
+ id = (known after apply)
}
# module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_admins will be created
+ resource "artifactory_group" "check_iz_group_admins" {
+ admin_privileges = false
+ auto_join = false
+ description = "IZ group"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ name = "swb2-izga-arti"
+ policy_manager = false
+ realm = "ldapimport"
+ reports_manager = false
+ watch_manager = false
}
# module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_members will be created
+ resource "artifactory_group" "check_iz_group_members" {
+ admin_privileges = false
+ auto_join = false
+ description = "IZ group"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ name = "swb2-izg-arti"
+ policy_manager = false
+ realm = "ldapimport"
+ reports_manager = false
+ watch_manager = false
}
# module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_owner will be created
+ resource "artifactory_group" "check_iz_group_owner" {
+ admin_privileges = false
+ auto_join = false
+ description = "IZ group"
+ id = (known after apply)
+ name = "swb2-izgo-arti"
+ policy_manager = false
+ realm = "ldapimport"
+ reports_manager = false
+ watch_manager = false
}
# module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_permission_target.set-repo-permissions will be created
+ resource "artifactory_permission_target" "set-repo-permissions" {
+ id = (known after apply)
+ name = "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce"
+ repo {
+ excludes_pattern = []
+ includes_pattern = [
+ "**",
]
+ repositories = [
+ "testremote-docker-release-arti-nce",
]
+ actions {
+ groups {
+ name = "every-logged-user"
+ permissions = [
+ "read",
]
}
+ groups {
+ name = "everyone"
+ permissions = [
+ "read",
]
}
+ groups {
+ name = "readers"
+ permissions = [
+ "annotate",
+ "read",
]
}
+ groups {
+ name = "swb2-izg-arti"
+ permissions = [
+ "read",
]
}
+ groups {
+ name = "swb2-izga-arti"
+ permissions = [
+ "annotate",
+ "delete",
+ "manage",
+ "read",
+ "write",
]
}
+ groups {
+ name = "swb2-izgo-arti"
+ permissions = [
+ "annotate",
+ "delete",
+ "manage",
+ "read",
+ "write",
]
}
+ users {
+ name = "searchuser"
+ permissions = [
+ "read",
]
}
+ users {
+ name = "swb2-izu-arti"
+ permissions = [
+ "annotate",
+ "delete",
+ "read",
+ "write",
]
}
}
}
}
# module.set-repo-permissions.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds will be created
+ resource "time_sleep" "wait_5_seconds" {
+ create_duration = "5s"
+ id = (known after apply)
}
Plan: 16 to add, 0 to change, 0 to destroy.
time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creating...
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository: Creating...
time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creation complete after 5s [id=2024-02-16T10:10:24Z]
module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository.create_local_repository: Creating...
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository: Creation complete after 4s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote]
restapi_object.add_repo_properties: Creating...
restapi_object.add_repo_properties: Creation complete after 1s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti-nce_set_properties]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository: Creating...
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_remote_docker_repository.create_remote_repository: Creation complete after 8s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti-nce-remote]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creating...
module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository.create_local_repository: Still creating... [10s elapsed]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creation complete after 5s [id=2024-02-16T10:10:39Z]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creating...
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creation complete after 5s [id=2024-02-16T10:10:44Z]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo: Creating...
module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository.create_local_repository: Still creating... [20s elapsed]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_muc.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo: Creation complete after 2s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti]
module.set-repo-permissions.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_owner: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_owner: Creation complete after 0s [id=swb2-izgo-arti]
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_members: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_members: Creation complete after 1s [id=swb2-izg-arti]
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_admins: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.time_sleep.wait_5_seconds: Creation complete after 5s [id=2024-02-16T10:10:50Z]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_group.check_iz_group_admins: Creation complete after 0s [id=swb2-izga-arti]
module.create-remote-repo-docker_blr.artifactory_virtual_docker_repository.create_virtual_repo: Creation complete after 1s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti]
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_permission_target.set-repo-permissions: Creating...
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_permission_target.set-repo-permissions: Still creating... [10s elapsed]
module.set-repo-permissions.artifactory_permission_target.set-repo-permissions: Creation complete after 15s [id=testremote-docker-release-arti-nce]
���
��� Error: Provider produced inconsistent result after apply
���
��� When applying changes to
��� module.create-repo-docker.artifactory_local_docker_v2_repository.create_local_repository,
��� provider "provider[\"registry.terraform.io/jfrog/artifactory\"]" produced
��� an unexpected new value: Root resource was present, but now absent.
���
��� This is a bug in the provider, which should be reported in the provider's
��� own issue tracker.
���
Thanks and Best Regards,
JM
alexhung commented
@jmvitali I have not been able to reproduce this issue by creating the Docker v2 repo itself. However, this may be a timing issue as suggested in this post. The log messages suggests the provider was taking a long time to create the repo so it is possible Artifactory was also doing something weird.
Not sure if this is related but I notice you have time_sleep resources between your JFrog resources. Is this to ensure resources are created in correct order?
alexhung commented
jmvitali commented
Hello @alexhung ,
Sorry for the late answer.
Yes you are right, we are using time_sleep to wait some seconds between local repository creation and related virtual repository creation.
I'm going to try increasing the time_sleep and see the result.
Yes, we are using provider alias but the name is something like provider = "site1".
I'll keep you informed.
Thanks for your time to help on that issue.
Best Regards,
JM
alexhung commented
@jmvitali Perhaps it isn't possible in your setup/configuration, the use of resource references or depends_on meta argument will help Terraform figures out the dependencies between resources and sequence them correctly. This is more deterministic than arbitrary sleep periods.
alexhung commented
jmvitali commented
Hello Alex,
Sorry for the late answer.
Thanks a lot for the management of that ticket.
I'll test the version v10.3.2 and check if the issue will be solved.
Best Regards,
JM
jmvitali commented
Hello Alex,
For information no more issue has been identified since the implementation of the version v10.3.2 :)
Thanks a lot.
Best Regards,
JM