jupyter-server/team-compass

Create new, empty repo to facilitate collaboration on the "notebook state" problem

Zsailer opened this issue · 12 comments

Zsailer commented

Hi folks,

In yesterday's server meeting, I proposed creating a new repo to explore solutions to the issue raised here: Proposal: Restore Notebook execution progress when a browser page is reload

We've seen a lot of interest on this issue from people representing different organizations. I'd like to focus this energy to a single place on Github so we can easily collaborate. This work will likely be larger than a single PR and require some explorative work. For that reason, I'd like to focus this work in a separate repo.

I'll open a vote in our private council repo. @jupyter-server/jupyter-server-council

In the meantime, what should we call this repo if it gets created?

Zsailer commented

Pinging folks who've been involved in the conversations: @matthewwiese @skukhtichev and @parul100495

Zsailer commented

In the meantime, what should we call this repo if it gets created?

How about: jupyter-server/jupyter_message_replay ?

  • 👍4
matthewwiese commented

@Zsailer jupyter-server/jupyter_message_replay is succinct enough for me!

parul100495 commented

The name looks good to me as well.

Zsailer commented

Some other names that were discuss:

  • kernel-playback
  • message-recovery
ivanov commented

How about "serverside-notebook-state"? "message replay" is one possible solution, but not the only one.

  • 👍1
Zsailer commented

The Server Team voted in favor of creating a new repo for this work 🚀! (8 Yes, 7 Abstain).

Let's create the repo during the meeting.

Zsailer commented

How about "serverside-notebook-state"? "message replay" is one possible solution, but not the only one.

@ivanov true. The problem is a bit broader than the notebook too—e.g. kernel state (say for a console, not a notebook document) needs restoration too.

matthewwiese commented

@Zsailer Could you add a placeholder README to the jupyter-server/message_replay repo? GitHub won't let me fork it and open a PR with the extension cookiecutter template because the repository is empty

blink1073 commented

Could you add a placeholder README to the jupyter-server/message_replay repo?

Done!

  • 👍1
  • ❤️1
Zsailer commented

Thank you @blink1073!

ivanov commented

For anyone following along, here's the link: https://github.com/jupyter-server/message_replay