kasir-barati/you-say

Fix keycloak's issue or use fusionauth

kasir-barati opened this issue · 3 comments

ferrerojosh/nest-keycloak-connect#153

Or keep keycloak
But as of now it is too much problem and fusionauth looks more promising than Keycloak

Why not keycloak?

  1. Uncertainties regarding the NodeJS/NestJS adapter
  2. Keycloakify
    • It is like a two sided blade
      • Hard to maintain and build it
      • Poses unnecessary challenges for developers
      • Not widely known
      • Hard to integrate it in the big picture; Using what it builds as my login theme in keycloak and use it with terraform
      • As long as I only need to deal with react I would be happier
      • Hard to pickup what you should do
  3. Really hard to pickup doc

As an objection to what I mentioned about Keycloakify, one might argue that customising FusionAuth login page and other pages is similarly intricate and lacks a straightforward solution. For better or worse, this involves working with FreeMarker files rather than react, additional layer of complexity.

Nevertheless, it's worth noting that at least FusionAuth comes with tailwind by default, providing a more convenient styling framework IMO. In essence, the challenge in both cases boils down to a learning curve

Refactored to use FusionAuth