Korg I30 issue
andr229k opened this issue · 8 comments
Environment:
Korg I30 with Gotek [SFRC992D/ARM STM32F105] and Flashfloppy version 3.41.
Jumper on JC and S1
interface = ibmpc-hdout
Host = akai < [due to information on https://github.com/keirf/flashfloppy/wiki/Host-Platforms#korg about .img]
Symptoms:
The LED on the Emulator is not giving any handshake at loading/saving nor formatting. [Which is a bit frustrating] Like there is no connection between Floppy Emulator and device.
Diagnose:
- Korg I30 does not use the default 34-pin [see pictures of cables and schematics].
- Floppy cable is okay, at it seem normal functional on the original drive.
- Someone in the FlashFloppy group “halfy-confirmed” above as working.
- Korg I30 can use both 2DD and HD disk [Seen in manual]
Actions:
- Removing Jumper from JC [same issue]
- Trying IBMPC as Interface [same issue]
Any ideas how to proceed?
Sounds about right to me. Pin 2 is not connected at the floppy drive, so ibmpc and ibmpc-hdout and even jc with JC jumpered should all be equivalent, giving the required DISK CHANGE on pin 34. And drive select is at pin 12, and that is indeed jumper position S1.
Sounds about right to me. Pin 2 is not connected at the floppy drive, so
ibmpcandibmpc-hdoutand evenjcwith JC jumpered should all be equivalent, giving the required DISK CHANGE on pin 34. And drive select is at pin 12, and that is indeed jumper position S1.
below is an example where:
Left side = What you see on disk-page, when original floppy-drive is inserted. [no disk in Floppy-drive but device is recogniced.]
Right side = What you see on disk-page, when Gotek or no drive is inserted. [ 'unformated' what means 'i dont find a device'!]
Are there any way to diagnostic, if something is not received correctly on the pins?
Are you testing the Gotek with no USB stick inserted, for now? This will be equivalent to a floppy drive with no disk inserted. It might make sense to get identical Gorg host behaviour between these two setups before proceeding.
There are five lines from the drive to the uPD72070 controller chip: INDEX, TRACK00, WRITE PROTECT, READ DATA, DISK CHANGE.
Assuming the Panasonic drive is a 1.44MB PC drive (which it appears to be) then when no disk inserted
- INDEX and READ DATA are masked (they should have no activity). This matches Gotek.
- TRACK00 should behave normally, as it will on Gotek.
- DISK CHANGE should be asserted (LOW), as it will be on Gotek when no disk image is mounted.
- WRITE PROTECT may or may not be asserted. Commonly it is (eg Atari ST uses this to detect disk changes). Gotek will assert this when no disk image is mounted.
So... there should be no reason to see a behavioural difference between an empty (no disk) floppy drive and an empty (no stick) Gotek.
Is the Gotek known good?
First the behave-profile without a USB-stick inserted, was the first test-scenario.
I was not able to find the manual for Panasonic ju-257a726p, but I found PANASONIC JU-257A-083P and I could imagine that it is close too, setting-option-wise. [I can try to make some more close-up photos of the backside options on original drive of the SW-holes]
The Gotek Emulator was sold on Amazon to a Premium price-point including the Factory firmware and a sticker on the top with I30 claiming-compatibility.
I can try with a newer Gotek with AT-chip set instead, if you think the Gotek drive is faulty. I could imagine, that AT-Chipset was similar environment as the person in FlashFloppy-Group, who claimed “plug’n’play” experience with S1 and JC.
Stick an AT in there and see what happens. Preferably a 435.
Just a last check-up before switching to AT-chipset and dumping the ST into the bin. See close-up pictures below, are there any settings you would define as "odd" or root-cause leading to issue?
Looks like bog standard PC configuration to me.