Crash in "View all sensors" on the new M3 Macbook Pro. Also no labeling for sensors.
varenc opened this issue · 5 comments
Hot mostly works, but when I try to open up the View All Sensors view and scroll around it crashes. If I don't scroll it doesn't crash, but as soon as I scroll a little bit it crashes.
Attached is the macOS crash report.
hot_crash_M3_mbp.txt
The crash seems to be caused here:
0 CoreFoundation 0x0000000189706800 __exceptionPreprocess + 176
1 libobjc.A.dylib 0x00000001891fdeb4 objc_exception_throw + 60
2 CoreFoundation 0x00000001897066f0 +[NSException exceptionWithName:reason:userInfo:] + 0
3 AppKit 0x000000018cf8c88c -[NSBezierPath lineToPoint:] + 72
4 Hot 0x0000000104fb9c8c Hot + 171148
5 Hot 0x0000000104fb8b9c Hot + 166812
6 Hot 0x0000000104fb8c4c Hot + 166988
7 AppKit 0x000000018cf83b20 _NSViewDrawRect + 124
While I'm here I'll mention that Hot also has poor labeling for the various M3 Macbook Pro sensors.
The CLI tool iSMC also struggles with labeling the sensors, though it does a better job at labeling at least some of them. Also attached is the iSMC output where you can see that at least a few of the sensors get helpful labels.
iSMC_mbp.json
iSMC_mbp.txt
On a M1 with MacOs 14.1.2, I can see these exact same issues.
Same crash & lack of sensor ID on a M2 Max Studio running 14.1.2
iSMC identified these:
Current
DESCRIPTION KEY VALUE TYPE
Mainboard S0 Rail (DC In) ID0R 0.8 A flt
PMU ibuck3 15.85 A hid
PMU ibuck8 16.03 A hid
PMU ibuck9 16.00 A hid
PMU ildo1 15.78 A hid
PMU ildo2 15.52 A hid
PMU ildo5 15.53 A hid
Fans
DESCRIPTION KEY VALUE TYPE
Fan 1 Current Speed F0Ac 1000 rpm flt
Fan 1 Maximum Speed F0Mx 3500 rpm flt
Fan 1 Minimal Speed F0Mn 1000 rpm flt
Fan 1 Target Speed F0Tg 1000 rpm flt
Fan 2 Current Speed F1Ac 995 rpm flt
Fan 2 Maximum Speed F1Mx 3500 rpm flt
Fan 2 Minimal Speed F1Mn 1000 rpm flt
Fan 2 Target Speed F1Tg 1000 rpm flt
Fan Count FNum 2 ui8
Power
DESCRIPTION KEY VALUE TYPE
Average CPU 1V5 PD1R 0.0 W flt
DC In PDTR 9.7 W flt
Heatpipe PHPC 4.6 W flt
Mainboard S0 Rail PD0R 9.7 W flt
System Total PSTR 9.7 W flt
Temperature
DESCRIPTION KEY VALUE TYPE
CPU Efficiency Core 1 Tp09 39.9 °C flt
CPU Performance Core 1 Tp01 40.6 °C flt
CPU Performance Core 2 Tp05 37.7 °C flt
CPU Performance Core 3 Tp0D 37.5 °C flt
CPU Performance Core 7 Tp0X 39.7 °C flt
CPU Performance Core 8 Tp0b 37.6 °C flt
Drive 0 OOBv3 Absolute Raw A TH0a 30.5 °C flt
Drive 0 OOBv3 Absolute Raw B TH0b 30.6 °C flt
Drive 0 OOBv3 Max TH0x 30.6 °C flt
Heat Spreader Proximity Th0P 32.6 °C flt
Heatpipe 1 Th0H 32.7 °C flt
NAND TH0x 30.6 °C flt
NAND CH0 temp 30.00 °C hid
PMU TP0s 35.80 °C hid
PMU TP1g 35.18 °C hid
PMU TP1s 35.62 °C hid
PMU TP2g 35.53 °C hid
PMU TP2s 35.80 °C hid
PMU TP3g 35.09 °C hid
PMU tcal 51.85 °C hid
PMU tdev1 34.00 °C hid
PMU tdev2 33.71 °C hid
PMU tdev3 33.76 °C hid
PMU tdev4 34.10 °C hid
PMU tdev5 32.94 °C hid
PMU tdev6 35.93 °C hid
PMU tdev7 32.70 °C hid
PMU tdev8 33.23 °C hid
PMU tdie0 35.44 °C hid
PMU tdie1 34.73 °C hid
PMU tdie2 35.26 °C hid
PMU tdie3 35.62 °C hid
PMU tdie4 35.80 °C hid
PMU tdie5 35.71 °C hid
PMU tdie6 35.44 °C hid
PMU tdie7 35.44 °C hid
PMU tdie8 35.89 °C hid
PMU tdie9 36.15 °C hid
PMU tdie10 35.35 °C hid
Power Supply 1 Alt Tp0C 32.9 °C flt
Power Supply 2 Alt Tp1C 45.2 °C flt
Power Supply T2 Secondary Heatsink Cooked Tp2H 39.2 °C flt
Speaker Proximity TS0P 33.6 °C flt
Speaker Proximity 2 TS1P 32.7 °C flt
Voltage
DESCRIPTION KEY VALUE TYPE
DC In VD0R 12.1 V flt
PMU VP0s 16.29 V hid
PMU vbuck0 16.21 V hid
PMU vbuck1 16.21 V hid
PMU vbuck3 16.36 V hid
PMU vbuck4 16.26 V hid
PMU vbuck5 16.17 V hid
PMU vbuck6 16.27 V hid
PMU vbuck7 16.16 V hid
PMU vbuck8 16.29 V hid
PMU vbuck9 16.21 V hid
PMU vbuck10 16.15 V hid
PMU vldo1 16.47 V hid
PMU vldo2 16.36 V hid
PMU vldo5 16.20 V hid
Same issue on M1. The associated standalone Sensors crashes the same way as well.
Also, both the View all Sensors and the Sensors.app are pretty CPU intensive (nearly 90% usage), instantly raising the temperatures by a lot periodically:
No idea if that's just the normal polling and expected, display or some other issues.
I have the same problem.
MBP - M1 Pro,
macOS 14.5 (23F79)
Fixed in 1.9.2: https://github.com/macmade/Hot/releases/tag/1.9.2