Silent Gear support uses wrong values
uhloin opened this issue · 3 comments
Issue description
If use refined obsidian ingots to create armor, then you use different stats then if create the same armor with silent gear templates.
For example:
Refined Obsidian Chestplate from ingots: +12 armor, +5 armor toughness, +2 knockback resistance, 1200 durability
Refined Obsidian Chestplate from template: +12 armor, +4 armor toughness, +0 knockback resistance, 800 durability
Also (not real bug, but balance issue) refined obsidian has values greater than final gameplay materials from End, but is accessible before Nether.
Armor value for helm/chestplate/leggins/boots:
Diamond (best Overworld material): 3/8/6/3
Crimson Steel (best Nether material): 4/8/6/4
Tyrian Steel (best End material): 5/9/7/4
Refined Obsidian: 5/12/8/5
This lead to another problem: any alloys of high tier materials with refined obsidian lead to worse material instead of improve it because of synergy.
The possible solution is to create several versions of refined obsidian ingots, with the same armor as for best materials, but better toughness and/or knockback resistance, like this:
Refined Obsidian (only overworld materials)
Blazed Obsidian (+blaze rod powder)
Warped Obsidian (+shulker powder)
Steps to reproduce
No response
Minecraft version
1.20.1 or earlier (No longer being developed)
NeoForge version
47.1.100
Mekanism version
Older
Other relevant versions
Mekanism-1.20.1-10.4.6.20.jar
MekanismTools-1.20.1-10.4.6.20.jar
silent-gear-1.20.1-3.6.3.jar
silent-lib-1.20.1-8.0.0.jar
If a (crash)log is relevant for this issue, link it here: (It's almost always relevant)
No response
If use refined obsidian ingots to create armor, then you use different stats then if create the same armor with silent gear templates.
That would be a bug on Silent's end, as we don't have any integration as far as I know
This lead to another problem: any alloys of high tier materials with refined obsidian lead to worse material instead of improve it because of synergy.
That would be a modpack-level concern, as it's a modpack task to ensure inter-mod balance
"That would be a bug on Silent's end, as we don't have any integration as far as I know"
You mean Silent made integration with Mekanism, but not Mekanism supported Silent?
I wrote a similar report to Silent team
Yes