mfdz/GTFS-Issues

Rheinbahn Bus: Trip stops on Station exit (type 2)

Closed this issue · 1 comments

stops.txt contains the following stop:

grep 'de:05158:19054:1' stops.txt
"de:05158:19054:1","","Erkrath Nord Bf","Zugang","51.229261000000","6.909293000000",2,"de:05158:19054_G",0,"","2"

marking it as entry/exit (type '2')

stop_times.txt is using that stop:

grep 'de:05158:19054:1' stop_times.txt
2008084914,9:13:30,9:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084921,10:13:30,10:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084917,10:43:30,10:43:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084920,11:13:30,11:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084916,11:43:30,11:43:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084919,12:13:30,12:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084915,12:43:30,12:43:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084918,13:13:30,13:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084913,14:13:30,14:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084912,15:13:30,15:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084911,16:13:30,16:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084910,17:13:30,17:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""
2008084909,18:13:30,18:13:30,"de:05158:19054:1",38,0,0,""

The correct value I assume would be 'de:05158:19054_G'

Source: DELFI-Datensatz_GTFS_20230102

Thanks for the issue report. I'll close this one, as it duplicates #72 which enumerates all stops with wrong types.

Regarding the correct stop_id, I assume it should be de:05158:19054:2:1, de:05158:19054:2:2 or de:05158:19054:2:3, which are bus quaies at Erkrath station. (stops with _G suffix are artifacts in DELFI's GTFS feed, which are not official stops according to the zHV (zentrales Haltestellenverzeichnis).