mtgjson/mtgjson3

Reprints in M19 are not listed

KingSupernova31 opened this issue ยท 14 comments

Cards in M19 that are reprints from an earlier set are not properly listed as being in M19. For example, Dragon Egg's printings are listed as just M14, EMA, and IMA. Cards that are exclusive to M19 do not have this issue.

This does not apply to all reprints. E.g. Knightly Valor still has M19 listed as a printing in AllCards-x.json.

This is similar to issue #594.

M19 problem cards I've noticed: Meandering River, Stone Quarry, Timber Gorge, Woodland Stream, Diregraf Ghoul, Switcheroo, Bone to Ash, Dragon Egg (as KingSupernova31 mentioned), Recollect, Gift of Paradise, Enigma Drake, Rogue's Gloves, Gargoyle Sentinel, Inspired Charge, Oreskos Swiftclaw, Totally Lost, Anticipate, Ghostform, Tolarian Scholar, Snapping Drake, Cancel, Disperse, Doomed Traveler, Child of Night, Mind Rot, Duress, Walking Corpse, Macabre Waltz, Smelt, Sure Strike, Trumpet Blast, Act of Treason, Shock, Electrify, Lava Axe, Tormenting Voice, Fire Elemental, Daggerback Basilisk, Centaur Courser, Oakenform, Naturalize, Highland Game, Wall of Vines, Giant Spider, Plummet, Druid of the Cowl, Titanic Growth, Field Creeper, Manalith

Rupture Spire too.

It seems like reprints that have been printed a lot (e.g. Lava Axe) are always missing, while others sometimes have the new set included.

In 9th edition, the card Greater Good does not show reprints for Battlebond.

I found more cards. I'm reorganizing the old and new ones into this comment, which I'll update if I find more:
White: Ajani's Pridemate, Inspired Charge, Oreskos Swiftclaw
Blue: Anticipate, Bone to Ash, Cancel, Disperse, Ghostform, Sift, Snapping Drake, Switcheroo, Tolarian Scholar, Totally Lost,
Black: Child of Night, Diregraf Ghoul, Doomed Dissenter, Duress, Gravedigger, Macabre Waltz, Mind Rot, Walking Corpse,
Red: Act of Treason, Dragon Egg, Fire Elemental, Lava Axe, Shock, Smelt, Sure Strike, Tormenting Voice, Trumpet Blast,
Green: Centaur Courser, Daggerback Basilisk, Druid of the Cowl, Giant Spider, Gift of Paradise, Greater Good, Highland Game, Naturalize, Oakenform, Plummet, Recollect, Titanic Growth, Wall of Vines
Multi-colored: Enigma Drake,
Artifact: Field Creeper, Gargoyle Sentinel, Manalith, Rogue's Gloves,
Land: Cinder Barrens, Forsaken Sanctuary, Foul Orchard, Meandering River, Reliquary Tower, Rupture Spire, Stone Quarry, Timber Gorge, Woodland Stream,

We need someone to attempt a rebuild as something did not work right last time.

Iโ€™ll get to it this week

The problem has been fixed for all cards listed above except for Act of Treason. Excellent!

Fixed in V4

Act of Treason is still missing here.

@paithan Is this an issue in v4? I don't believe v3 is still being supported.

I don't know about the version numbers. When I download the new json files and use them, M19 isn't listed as a printing of Act of Treason.

If you're having an issue with v4, you should open a ticket there. Any problems with v3 are most likely never going to be fixed.