ncopa/su-exec

"setgroups" operation not permitted?

swquinn opened this issue · 5 comments

swquinn commented

Hi, after installing su-exec on an Alpine-based image for Docker I tried running it and received the following output: su-exec: setgroups: Operation not permitted

Below is a simple Dockerfile and test showing what I'm seeing.

Dockerfile

FROM alpine

RUN  apk update
RUN  apk add --no-cache bash su-exec \
 &&  rm -rf /var/cache/apk/*

RUN addgroup -g 82 -S www-data \
 && adduser -u 82 -D -S -G www-data www-data

USER www-data

Command

# su-exec root /bin/bash
su-exec: setgroups: Operation not permitted
swquinn commented

OK, so I think I just answered my own question. It looks like after installing su-exec it doesn't have the proper permissions to be able to execute under a different user. It looks like running chmod u+s /sbin/su-exec during the build gets everything working.

Sorry for wasting your time!

ncopa commented

i don't think it is a good idea to chmod u+s it as it means that any user could run as root. The purpose of this tool is to drop root permissions, not to elevate permissions. Use sudo if you need elevate permissions.

  • 👍3
swquinn commented

Ah, interesting. OK. I guess I had misunderstood its usage when I read the example that used the command: su-exec root ...

Thanks for the clarification!

  • 👍1
hlovdal commented

This issue should be closed since Dockerfile's USER directive is incompatible with su-exec.

This can be seen in the Best practices for building secure Docker images video. Without USER specified docker exec container_name ps will run ps as root (~6 minutes in), but when USER is specified everything starts running as this user (~8 minutes in).

binarymist commented

What's your solution @hlovdal to this then: moby/moby#2259
Obviously this won't work: https://denibertovic.com/posts/handling-permissions-with-docker-volumes/

The incompatibility is also not mentioned here: https://github.com/ncopa/su-exec