olsh/resharper-structured-logging

Convert to compile time constant codefix should cover more cases

MichalBrylka opened this issue · 2 comments

Hi,
The "Convert to compile time constant message template" generally works and produces nice results:
image

Where it falls short is when presented with more challenging (but sadly, more frequent) structured logging bad practice i.e.:

log.InfoFormat("Name:" + name + " age " + age);

No code fix is presented in such case:
image

While it might be tempting to add support for such bad-practices fixes, I'd propose to alternatively allow R# to use it's own "Convert concatenation to interpolation" action:
image

Your plugin somehow prohibits this action from displaying in suggestion list

Would it be feasible to allow R# to propose it's own suggestions/code fixes ?

Using "Convert concatenation to interpolation" followed by your code fix would allow many ill-structured logging calls to be mended

olsh commented

Hi @MichalBrylka

Your plugin somehow prohibits this action from displaying in suggestion list

The plugin doesn't prohibit any fixes explicitly.
I get the same results whether the plugin is installed or not.

            var s = new Random().Next();
            
            // There is a fix for this
            var hello = "Hello" + s + "World";
            
            // There is no fix for this
            _logger.LogInformation("Hello" + s + "World");
olsh commented

Closed due to inactivity