Additional tags for buildings
Closed this issue · 5 comments
I'd like to make these adjustments to the tags, based on an email sent forever ago by Steve All, who sent along some handy suggestions. I've finally reviewed the data and think we can use the top portion after some discussion. I've left my notes on not importing the group in the bottom section.
This one is mine that I've noticed in large buildings being called building=house and building:units=1. It's because the building sits on several "stacked" parcels for each individual condominium (an owned apartment in a larger building).
We'd need to scrub anything that is "SpecificUseDetail2" as "Condominium" to be building=residential.
The rest below are all based on the "SpecificUseDetail1" column in the assessor file.
To change:
Building Supplies (Home Depot, etc.)
shop=doityourself
This appears to be all do it yourself type shops, so this could work. 60 instances.
Cemetery, Mausoleum
amenity=grave_yard, amenity=crematorium
It's not clear which ones are actually crematoriums, where bodies are burned. But I think amenity=grave_yard would work. 331 parcels.
Convalescent Hospital, Nursing Home
amenity=social_facility
social_facility=assisted_living
social_facility=day_care
All of these have a SpecificUseType of "Hospital." I suppose we could add these other tags. 136 instances.
"Hotel - 50 Rooms and Over" and "Hotel - Under 50 Rooms"
tourism=hotel
Good add. 1,060 instances.
Legitimate (Stage) Theater
amenity=theatre
Good add. 51 instances.
"Motel - 50 Rooms and Over" and "Motel - Under 50 Rooms"
tourism=motel
Good add. 1,085 instances.
Parking Structures - Commercial Parking
amenity=parking
Appears to be accurate, based on county's satellite in assessor map. 94 instances.
Parking Structures - Patron or Employee
amenity=parking
access=private
Also appears in county satellite imagery. 206 instances.
Petroleum Refinery
man_made=works
product=petroleum
Seems to work. There are a lot of man_made=storage_tank on these properties, which we've mostly corrected for. 109 properties.
Single Residence
building=house
These are manufactured homes. Should be building=house
1,702 parcels.
Small Food Store
shop=convenience
This works. 133 instances.
Not worth changing:
Beverage
shop=beverage
These are all industrial food processing plants and will get building=industrial
Church Parking Lot
amenity=parking
There are several of these descriptions, but they describe the entire property, which includes buildings (like churches or mosques) and parking lots (separate from the buildings). L.A. County recently released a parking lot shapefile which we could use to import parking spots.
Discount Department Store
shop=variety_store
These are coming in already as shop=department_store based on the SpecificUseType of "Department Store."
Fee Owned Boat Slip
leisure=slipway
fee=yes
There are only two buildings in the whole set with this. Look like errors, where the parcel boundary bisects a building (and cuts off a sliver).
Gymnasium, Health Spa
leisure=fitness_centre
Weirdly Disney Studio's in Burbank is classified as this. All 44 buildings come over with that description. Most definitely an error in the county's data. Other parcels include LA Fitness, but have multiple buildings like Target and restaurants on that property.
Home Furnishings
shop=furniture
These all have the SpecificUseType of "Department Store," which is a little more generic. Some of the properties have buildings with jewelry shops and other things.
Horse Stable
leisure=horse_riding
Not all of these properties appear to be this anymore.
Movie - Drive-in
amenity=cinema + drive_in=yes
This only affects six properties, but it's hard to verify if they're still drive-in theaters.
Movie - Indoor
amenity=cinema
These tend to not be standalone structures and instead are part of something else, such as a nearby department store.
Restaurant, Cocktail Lounge, Tavern
amenity=bar
Not always standard. Sometimes the building has several other non-restaurant businesses inside a strip mall.
Supermarket
shop=supermarket
Many of these properties have multiple buildings with different uses. Like a grocery store next to a pharmacy and a furniture store.
Trailer and Camper Park
tourism=caravan_site
Would be better as an area than a building type.
Veterinary Hospital
amenity=veterinary
Doesn't seem to be very accurate.
Warehousing
building=warehouse
Should already be caught by parent Warehousing category.
Wireless Communications Tower
man_made=tower
Towers do not appear to make it into the building file (too thin).
All SpecificUseDetail and count (these are just individual properties and not unique buildings)
4 Stories or Less 245080
5 Stories or More 1260
Adult Care Facility - Social and Recreational Services 14
Adult Day Services - Skilled Care Services Offered 8
Amusement Facility 25
Artist in Residence 116
Auditorium, Stadium, Amphitheater 130
Auto Body Repair Shop 6639
Auto Service Centers (No Gasoline) 488
Beverage 29
Building Supplies (Home Depot, etc.) 60
Car Wash Only 232
Car Wash Only, Self-service Type 145
Cement, Rock and Gravel Plant 50
Cemetery, Mausoleum 331
Church Parking Lot 256
Commercial Swimming Pools, School 20
Concessions 9
Contractor Storage Yard 64
Convalescent Hospital, Nursing Home 136
Dance Hall 23
Detached 6425
Discount Department Store (Target, etc.) 87
Farm and Construction Equipment Sales and Service 27
Fast Food - Auto Oriented 439
Fast Food - Walk Up 563
Fee Owned Boat Slip 331
Full Service 1544
Government Services 465
Gymnasium, Health Spa 113
High Rise 5 Stories or More 6184
High Value Residence, X Cost Classification 463
Home Furnishings (Ethan Allen, etc.) 12
Horse Stable - Private 32
Hotel - 50 Rooms and Over 558
Hotel - Under 50 Rooms 502
Ice 56
Legitimate (Stage) Theater 51
Loft-type Buildings 134
Lots - Commercial Parking 305
Lots - Patron or Employee 13136
Meat 370
Medical Dental Building 1578
Microwave Relay Tower 17
Miniature 2
Misc. Privately Owned Properties That Do Not Fall Into Any Other Classification 88
Miscellaneous 492
Miscellaneous Commercial 616
Miscellaneous Industrial 399
Mortuary, Funeral Home 54
Motel - 50 Rooms and Over 251
Motel - Under 50 Rooms 834
Motel/Hotel and Apartment Combinations - 50 Units and Over 25
Motel/Hotel and Apartment Combinations - Under 50 Units 34
Movie - Drive-in 6
Movie - Indoor 112
Multiple Residence 7
New Car Sales and Service 372
Non Profit 11
Office and Residential 560
Other 181
Own-your-own Lot 25
Parking Structures - Commercial Parking 94
Parking Structures - Patron or Employee 206
Petroleum Refinery, Chemical Plant 109
Private Rural Pumping Plant 136
Public School 751
Public Storage (Bekins, Lyons) 44
Public Storage - Mini Warehouse 529
Recreation 467
Recreation Equipment Sales and Service (Campers, Motor Homes and Boats) 58
Restaurant, Cocktail Lounge, Tavern 4762
Retail-Warehouse Combo (Levitz, etc.) 38
Rights of Way 188
Roller 1
Self Service 327
Single Residence 1702
Small Food Store - Less than 6,000 SF 133
Store and Office Combination 3719
Store and Residential Combination 8938
Studio 302
Supermarket - 12,000 SF or More 494
Supermarket - 6,000 SF through 11,999 SF 55
Tennis Court, Club, Pro Shop 46
Three Par 21
Townhouse Format 8395
Trailer and Camper Park (Overnight) 7
Transmission Facility 31
Transportation 237
Trucking Company, Terminal 122
Used Car Sales 381
Veterinary Hospital, Clinic 156
Warehouse Store (Costco, etc.) 53
Warehousing, Distribution, 10,000 to 24,999 SF 2096
Warehousing, Distribution, 25,000 to 50,000 SF 1262
Warehousing, Distribution, Over 50,000 SF 1677
Warehousing, Distribution, Under 10,000 SF 7358
Water Related Facilities 718
Wireless Communication Tower 587
With Car Wash 133
@jschleuss This is great! Can you edit the csv so I can rerun the script?
One question, what do we do with those that were already imported?
@maning Yes! I'll edit that today. I don't think it'll be that bad to update those already on the map. We can use overpass turbo or maybe make a Maproulette project out of it. I can be responsible since I took so long to look through the data and think of what actually works.
Oh, the "condominium" one will be harder because there are 18,150 unique locations. Yeah, that could be painful. Similarly could be a Maproulette project to just remove building=house and building:units=1 and replace with building=residential.
But I've seen it a lot and it's awkward to see a building:units=1 on a huge building.
@maning I think the scripting is mostly good. I was going to edit the shapefile for the condominiums. Or, maybe we could add that to the osm_tags.py file. Can't remember if we included the SpecificUseDetail2 in that file or not. Waiting for it to download on slow internet.
This is done and ready for import.