pkg/profile

Add NoProfile

josharian opened this issue · 3 comments

For programs that have both non-trivial shutdown hook plumbing and flags controlling profiling, it'd be convenient to have a NoProfile option with a no-op Stop function. I'll send a PR if you're amenable.

gbbr commented

This sounds good to me considering that:

gbbr commented

Some thoughts I have on this are:

  • Calling it NoProfile would create some stutter in the external context, where you would use it as profile.NoProfile. Personally I would prefer something like profile.Off if this is something that we really need.

  • Would you be able to provide a more thorough example of how you would use this? As far as I can see it, the current implementation already allows you to conditionally run profiles via flags or other means. I think adding this additional code might unnecessarily complicate an otherwise simple package, unless I'm missing the point. You can simply do something like:

var p interface {
    Stop()
}
if condition {
    p = profile.Start(/* your options */)
}

// ... 

if p != nil {
    p.Stop()
}

Am I misunderstanding something or is this the same use case?

Hello, is this issue still valid ?