ppy/osu-resources

Several flags have incorrect details

Poyo-SSB opened this issue · 2 comments

There are a few details that hold cultural value in some flags that were ignored for the purpose of designing nicer images. Notably:

  • China (CN): The four small stars should be pointed towards the larger star. The 2016 Summer Olympics at Rio failed to adhere to this.
  • Ethiopia (ET): The emblem in the center of the flag is quite heavily emphasized by the government.
  • Micronesia (FM): The four stars should be pointing in each of the four cardinal directions.
  • United Kingdom (GB): The red saltire of St. Patrick should be offset. This isn't really offensive, but it does look silly to ignore.
  • Guyana (GY): While unlikely to cause offense, this representation of the flag is really poorly made. All the triangles should be vertically centered and the white/yellow triangles should extend to the right side of the flag.
  • Israel (IL): As a religious symbol representing (in the modern day) Judaism, it's probably best to not stylize the Star of David.
  • India (IN): As a spiritual symbol, the Ashoka Chakra (the 24-spoked wheel) should probably not be simplified.
  • Cambodia (KH): This one's simply incorrect. The central band should be red and the outer bands should be blue, not vice versa.
  • Comoros (KM): As a symbol of Islam, the crescent (and stars) should probably not be distorted as they are.
  • South Korea (KR): The four black trigrams represent national values, but have been reduced to meaningless double lines.
  • Sri Lanka (LK): The golden lion on the left side of the flag is completely missing.
  • Morocco (MA): As with Israel, the pentagram is a religious symbol (Seal of Solomon) and should not be simplified.
  • Mauritania (MR): The red stripes on the top and bottom are completely missing.
  • Maldives (MV): The center is completely incorrect. It should not be blue, it should be green.

Generally, the star-and-crescent symbol is depicted inconsistently, sometimes using a circle in place of the star.

There are certain similar details that are also missing which I've excluded because they're not culturally significant. Most of the ones I have listed are also probably insignificant as well, so this entire issue is not a big problem.

I would probably bodge this. I'm bored anyway

peppy commented

Please file this issue against osu-web, where we have already begun to fix flags on a per-flag basis in cases people actually care. Note that you will need to re-checck those that you mentioned as I believe a few may be fixed.