puppetlabs/facter

Unsupported container runtime 'lxc' with facter 4.8.0+ / nightly

torstenfohrer opened this issue · 9 comments

torstenfohrer commented

Describe the Bug

Since facter 4.8.0 we getting unsupported container runtime 'lxc'

Problem origin here facter source

Expected Behavior

Support 'lxc' as runtime again, perhaps additional to 'lxcroot'

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Setup a lxc
  2. Install puppet-agent 8.8.0 (aka 8.7.0.38.gc055f2ce8-1noble)
  3. Simple run facter resulting in following output (stripped down)

[2024-07-08 10:23:33.166466 ] WARN Facter::Resolvers::Containers - Container runtime, 'lxc', is unsupported, setting to, 'container_other'

Environment

  • Puppet agent 8.8.0, (nightly 8.7.0.38.gc055f2ce8-1noble)
  • Facter 4.8.0
  • Ubuntu 20.04, 22.04, 24.04

Additional Context

See also at systemd source: https://github.com/systemd/systemd/blob/cd8eb9605f1a1f2fe1180382201d23548cad7a1c/src/nspawn/nspawn.c#L3500

joshcooper commented

@lollipopman 7bc38cc may have broken lxc could you take a look?

joshcooper commented

This is caused by #2574

deemon87 commented

Hi,
i also have the same issue inside lxc container

facter is_virtual
[2024-07-29 08:46:41.170292 ] WARN Facter::Resolvers::Containers - Container runtime, 'lxc', is unsupported, setting to, 'container_other'
true

  • 👍1
aqueos commented

same here on debian guest all facter virtual fail to work with lxd.

[~]: facter virtual
[2024-07-29 15:35:28.953018 ] WARN Facter::Resolvers::Containers - Container runtime, 'lxc', is unsupported, setting to, 'container_other'
container_other

completly broke a lot of pp script and templates :(

[~]: facter version
4.8.0

ii puppet-agent 7.32.1-1bookworm amd64 The Puppet Agent package contains ....
ii puppet7-release 7.0.0-20bookworm all Release packages for the Puppet 7 repository

  • 👍1
lollipopman commented

@lollipopman 7bc38cc may have broken lxc could you take a look?

will do

joshcooper commented

Can folks on this thread try out @lollipopman patch in #2741?

github-actions commented

Migrated issue to FACT-3477

aqueos commented

hi,

just FYI the issue still exist for me

[~]: dpkg -l 'puppet'|grep ii
ii puppet-agent 7.32.1-1focal amd64 The Puppet Agent package contains all of the elements needed to run

[~]: puppet facts|grep virtual
Warning: Facter: Container runtime, 'lxc', is unsupported, setting to, 'container_other'
"is_virtual": true,
"virtual": "container_other",

i cannot follow the link to https://perforce.atlassian.net/browse/FACT-3477 to see the rest but this vital fact is still not working on lxc/lxd for me :)

best regards,
Ghislain.

lollipopman commented

I don't think the fix has made it into any release, you would need to use git HEAD to test.

$ git tag --contains c609d1c9f