Correct language about posts using the word channel
Assile opened this issue · 7 comments
Amendment type
Content Update
Content type
Other
Please provide the location of the content
Discord Server
What amendment do you think should be made to this content, and why?
For example in the #❔｜how-to-get-help channel we have the following text:
Your channel will automatically close after 30 minutes of inactivity, or if you run the !close command. If your question relates to one of the topics under Topical Chat/Help, you can consider asking there instead.
Which I believe would be better worded with Your post will ....
Another example can be found in the help post messages. This was recently discussed in relation to python-discord/bot#1295.
Would https://www.pythondiscord.com/pages/guides/pydis-guides/help-channel-guide/#frequently-asked-questions also need to be taken into account for this change?
Would https://www.pythondiscord.com/pages/guides/pydis-guides/help-channel-guide/#frequently-asked-questions also need to be taken into account for this change?
What do you think needs to be changed for this? Replacing channel with post?
Would https://www.pythondiscord.com/pages/guides/pydis-guides/help-channel-guide/#frequently-asked-questions also need to be taken into account for this change?
What do you think needs to be changed for this? Replacing channel with post?
Yes, that's my thinking. If a 'channel' under a Forum channel is considered a post, then some of the mentions of the word channel here should also be changed to the word post, right?
Yes, that's my thinking. If a 'channel' under a Forum channel is considered a post, then some of the mentions of the word channel here should also be changed to the word post, right?
Theoretically, yes.
The thing here is that, technically, it isn't. And that's because these posts are threads IIRC.
There is some nuance between both, and it caused some sort of "confusion" or debate on what they need to be called. And I think channel was chosen because it's they're quite common across users as channels, even though a post is just sort of façade and new way to create a new "channel", which also has a title.
Theoretically, yes.
The thing here is that, technically, it isn't. And that's because these posts are threads IIRC.
There is some nuance between both, and it caused some sort of "confusion" or debate on what they need to be called. And I think channel was chosen because it's they're quite common across users as channels, even though a post is just sort of façade and new way to create a new "channel", which also has a title.
Fair enough, do you think this warrants not changing any of the language, or to just keep the language on the help page unchanged?
Fair enough, do you think this warrants not changing any of the language, or to just keep the language on the help page unchanged?
I wouldn't say it warrants not changing any of the language, but the language on the help page has been reviewed & I think that was what we had agreed upon. So first instinct would be to have everything in that fashion.
But we can see what others have to say about this.
I don't think this is worth changing, I think "help post", "help thread", and "help channel" are pretty much equally understandable.
The first thing sent when someone creates a post is "Python pinned a message to this channel.", so even Discord itself isn't particularly consistent.