Google Fonts Onboarding: QA FAIL: Each font in a family must have the same set of vertical metrics values.

[eliheuer]

Google Fonts onboarding uses FontBakery for QA. All FAIL level checks from the universal, opentype and googlefonts profiles must be passing in order to onboard fonts to Google Fonts. Exceptions can be made if necessary.

See the Quality Assurance section of the Google Fonts Guide for more information: https://googlefonts.github.io/gf-guide/qa.html

🔥 FAIL: Each font in a family must have the same set of vertical metrics values.
(com.google.fonts/check/family/vertical_metrics)

🔥 FAIL usWinAscent is not the same across the family:
Reddit Sans ExtraBold Italic: 2564
Reddit Sans Bold: 2455
Reddit Sans ExtraBold: 2492
Reddit Sans SemiBold: 2416
Reddit Sans Italic: 2441
Reddit Sans Light: 2309
Reddit Sans: 2356
Reddit Sans SemiBold Italic: 2496
Reddit Sans Light Italic: 2400
Reddit Sans Bold Italic: 2530 [code: usWinAscent-mismatch]

🔥 FAIL usWinDescent is not the same across the family:
Reddit Sans ExtraBold Italic: 580
Reddit Sans Bold: 603
Reddit Sans ExtraBold: 624
Reddit Sans SemiBold: 583
Reddit Sans Italic: 543
Reddit Sans Light: 523
Reddit Sans: 550
Reddit Sans SemiBold Italic: 559
Reddit Sans Light Italic: 530
Reddit Sans Bold Italic: 570

See the vertical metrics section of the Google Fonts Guide for more information: https://googlefonts.github.io/gf-guide/metrics.html

[eliheuer]

Of all the issues that need to be addressed for Google Fonts onboarding, this is one of the most important and urgent ones.

[stephenhutchings]

This should be fixed in the latest version (v1.012) of the fonts.