samuelduchesne/archetypal

JOSS paper acronyms

Closed this issue · 1 comments

brynpickering commented

Another JOSS review issue! Once again, just a minor one.

You should check your use of acronyms. M in BEM is given as Models but at one point is used in a way that means modelling. UBEM is given in full form twice in the document, once with the M referring to Models and once referring to Modelling. I would also not say UBEM models as it sounds weird when you think it means Urban Building Energy Modelling models.

In fact, my preference would be to avoid using both BEM and UBEM in your paper, just use the phrases in full form. It doesn't add much to the paper length, but does aid in clarity.

Note: this issue comes to you as part of my wider JOSS review

samuelduchesne commented

Hi @brynpickering, I've always struggled with these acronyms. You are right. I've removed most of them but I kept the first UBEM since is quite the buzzword in this field. ;)

Closing this