scraly/developers-conferences-agenda

json and atom feeds might be invalid

Opened this issue · 7 comments

jonatan-ivanov commented

Json and atom feeds were introduced in #604. When I try to add them on feedly, both fail. The W3C feed validation service also says that the atom feed is invalid.

jespino commented

I can take care of this :)

  • 👍1
scraly commented

thanks :)

scraly commented

atom feed is now valid

jonatan-ivanov commented

Thank you!

Unfortunately, I'm still not able to add it to Feedly, as it seems @jespino was not able to do it either.

I have two guesses for that, neither should be an issue I think but we don't really know why feedly does not work:

  1. The validator still prints out a warning for this:
<link rel="self" href="https://developers.events/feed-events.atom"/>

Which is not the link to the feed, the feed is under /feed-events.xml.
2. This also makes me wondering that Atom feed urls usually (not always) use the .atom extension instead of xml (I guess mainly to distinguish between .atom and .rss but I'm not an expert in either of those).

scraly commented

I fixed the warning (in #707) for ATOM feed but we still can't import ATOM and JSON feeds on feedly

scraly commented

By the way, atom feed accepts .atom and .xml

jonatan-ivanov commented

Thank you for fixing it.
Yeah, it should not matter, neither of the above should be an issue I think for any readers but now that this is fixed and feedly is still broken, I'm out of ideas.

I tweeted them, let's see if they reply: https://twitter.com/jonatan_ivanov/status/1716279676631716019