steve-community/steve

Cannot start transaction when tag already holds an active transaction

Closed this issue · 6 comments

Smoerrebroed commented

Checklist

  • I checked other issues already, but found no answer/solution
  • I checked the documentation and wiki, but found no answer/solution
  • I am running the latest version and the issue still occurs
  • I am sure that this issue is about SteVe (and not about the charging station software or something unrelated to SteVe)

Specifications

While a transaction is already in progress for a given tag, I want to start a second transaction on a different charge point. Tag is configured with Max. Active Transaction Count of -1.

SteVe Version : 3.6.0
Operating system : Linux
JDK : 21.0.1
Database : MariaDB 11.2.2


#### Expected Behavior

Second transaction starts normally.

#### Actual Behavior

Charge point (SteVe) denies initiation of second transaction; remote starting a transaction is not possible as the tag is not even selectable from the drop-down list.

#### Steps to Reproduce the Problem

  1. Set up OCPP tag with Max. Active Transaction Count > 1
  2. Start a transaction for this tag
  3. Try to start a second transaction (on another charge point) for this tag.
fnkbsi commented

Hi Smoerrebroed,

could you please clarify in which case the problem occurs?

  1. Max. Active Transaction Count > 1
  2. Max. Active Transaction Count == -1
  3. both cases

Providing a log may also help isolate the problem.

Smoerrebroed commented

It's both cases. I don't normally use a limit on the number of transactions (-1), but I also tried with 2 and 10, and it didn't make a difference. Neither is the physical tag accepted at the charge point (when another transaction is already in progress) nor can I remote start an additional transaction for a tag that already has a transaction in progress.

What would you like to see in the log? I mostly tried with remote start transaction, and that doesn't even let me choose a tag that is already in use.

fnkbsi commented

PR #1378 addresses the missing ocpp_tag on the RemoteStart website, when max transaction count is not reached.

  • ❤️1
  • 🚀1
Smoerrebroed commented

Great, will test it out tomorrow. If getActiveIdTags() is only used for remote start of transactions, a similar change would be needed for a local start of a transaction, no? That failed previously as well when there was already a transaction in progress for the same (physical) tag.

fnkbsi commented

Hi @Smoerrebroed, did you have time to test? Is the issue resolved or only partly?

Smoerrebroed commented

Hi @fnkbsi , sorry for the late response (due to some personal issues which caused delays in getting this done). So I did test different cases now

  • Initiate transaction # 1 via physical tag and transaction # 2 via physical tag
  • Initiate transaction # 1 via physical tag and transaction # 2 via remote start (same tag)
  • Initiate transaction # 1 via remote start and transaction # 2 via (same) physical tag
  • Initiate transaction # 1 via remote start and transaction # 2 via remote start (same tag)

and I'm happy to report that all seem to be working with the latest version, so from my side the issue is solved. Thank you very much for your efforts and support!

  • 🎉2