incompatibility of `dendextend::cutree` with `cluster` objects

[GillesSanMartin]

Loading dendextend causes cutree to return an error when applied on cluster obsjects (agnes, diana).
This breaks some other packages like clValid.

Error in cutree.default(clusterObj, nc) :
Function cutree is only available for hclust/dendrogram/phylo objects only.

See for example this SO question (with reproducible example) :
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52319709

Would it be possible to do something from dendextend to avoid that ?

[talgalili]

Hi @GillesSanMartin ,
I've just pushed a new version of dendextend.

Before the fix:

> library(cluster)
> a <- diana(votes.repub, metric = "manhattan", stand = TRUE)
> dendextend::cutree(a, k=3)
 Show Traceback
 
 Rerun with Debug
 Error in cutree.default(a, k=3) : 
  Function cutree is only available for hclust/dendrogram/phylo objects only. 

After the fix:

library(cluster)
a <- diana(votes.repub, metric = "manhattan", stand = TRUE)
dendextend::cutree(a, k= 3)

> dendextend::cutree(a, k= 3)
       Alabama         Alaska        Arizona       Arkansas     California       Colorado    Connecticut 
             1              2              3              1              3              3              3 
      Delaware        Florida        Georgia 
etc...

Please confirm that it works for you as well?

[GillesSanMartin]

Waouh that was quick !
It works indeed with the new dendextend 1.10.0
I will modify the SO answer to point to this better solution...

Thanks for the quick response and for developing such an excellent package !

[talgalili]

My pleasure, thanks for the bug report :)