Make Upcase Open Source
juandazapata opened this issue · 16 comments
This is a great app for people who wants to learn and peek a well coded app. Also handy for people who wants to create their own online school. Why not open sourcing it?
Just to clarify, I'm not talking about open sourcing the content (which has way more value IMO), I mean open sourcing the platform.
I'd imagine that the privilege of viewing this code is one of the major incentives driving the platform's success.
@stevenpetryk - As a paying user for over a year now, I have to agree with you. However, I didn't see it being promoted that much.
This issue can probably be closed now that Upcase is free.
The repo is still private, though.
I didn’t read the OP’s request closely enough.
Now that Upcase is free there’s no major barrier to being able to view the source (the major incentive you referred to previously).
But you’re right, the source being free (as in beer) and therefore open to anyone to view is not the same as it being free (as in speech) and open source.
I don't really understand what are the limitations/permissions of the project's license. It only mentions what happens if you submit a Contribution.
Can anyone elaborate? What happens if you decide to fork and change the codebase, and maybe even publish it as free or commercial product?
Here's the c/p from the README.md:
License
This application is Copyright © 2007 thoughtbot, inc.
If you submit a Contribution to this application's source code, you hereby grant
to thoughtbot, inc. a worldwide, royalty-free, exclusive, perpetual and
irrevocable license, with the right to grant or transfer an unlimited number of
non-exclusive licenses or sublicenses to third parties, under the Copyright
covering the Contribution to use the Contribution by all means, including but
not limited to:
- to publish the Contribution,
- to modify the Contribution, to prepare Derivative Works based upon or
containing the Contribution and to combine the Contribution with other
software code, - to reproduce the Contribution in original or modified form,
- to distribute, to make the Contribution available to the public, display and
publicly perform the Contribution in original or modified form.
@vfonic That is a grey area, But you can read the code and fork it. You can't redistribute it https://opensource.stackexchange.com/questions/1720/what-can-i-assume-if-a-publicly-published-project-has-no-license
Closing this issue as Upcase is now open source
@SViccari that's great news!
I believe my question is still not answered though. What are the rules/limitations of forking this project and making a webapp out of it? For example if I'd create my own platform "downcase"? What if I wanted to charge for the use of the platform?
The license doesn't cover any of these questions.
I believe this question is extremely important, especially in these days.
Should I open a new issue?
Thanks!
Repository is public, but there is no explicit mention that this project is open source nor a license file is committed to the repo.
Can you please add a license ?
Hey @SViccari!
Thank you for looking into this!
It would save a ton of time if upcase would be truly open source and it would help greatly in these times.
Can you please check with the team and let me know what you decided?
Thank you!
Thanks for asking! It's a learning platform that can be used to...well...build learning platform(s).
And today, when everything suddenly moved online, it could be of great help for so many people:
- people willing to learn online
- people willing to offer teaching online
- companies giving seminars / workshops online
- ...
If there's a platform that's extensible, developers could use it to build their online learning platforms. And that's where upcase comes in.
EDIT: Oh wow! Just saw that this is getting licensed under the MIT license! Thank you!
We just merged in the MIT license update.