"The text associated with this error code could not be found" error with UnitsNet and MVUX model on Windows

Question

"The text associated with this error code could not be found" error with UnitsNet and MVUX model on Windows

igiona opened this issue 5 months ago · 9 comments

Current behavior

Hi

In my application, I have a pretty simple model which contains a UnitsNet Ratio object.

public record DeviceStateModel(
    bool OperationIsInProgress,
    bool IsConnected,
    Ratio? BatteryStateOfCharge
);

I initialize the IState as follow:

    public IState<DeviceStateModel> DeviceState => State<DeviceStateModel>.Value(this, () => new(
        false,
        false,
        null
    ));

and in different places of the code I updated the model value, for example:

var deviceState = await DeviceState ?? throw new InvalidOperationException("Unable to get the current model state");
await DeviceState.Update(_ => deviceState with { OperationIsInProgress = true, BatteryStateOfCharge = Ratio.FromPercent(Random.Shared.Next(0, 100)) }, CancellationToken.None);

The BatteryStateOfCharge property is bind as follow:

<TextBlock Text="{Binding DeviceState.BatteryStateOfCharge}" Style="{StaticResource TitleSmall}" VerticalAlignment="Center" />

On iOS&Android I don't issues, on Windows though the after sending the device state update, within 1-2 seconds I get a Microsoft.UI.Xaml.LayoutCycleException with the following message: Layout cycle detected. Layout could not complete.

The text associated with this error code could not be found.

Layout cycle detected.  Layout could not complete.

More details

Expected behavior

The app doesn't crash.

How to reproduce it (as minimally and precisely as possible)

Unfortunately I've not been able to repro this issue with a simple app.
The app with the actual crash is slightly more complex, and uses a BLE connection, SQLite...
I'm not sure if any of this is actually related though.

Any suggestion on what I can debug/further investigate the issue is welcomed.

A repro tentative (which doesn't actually reproduce the issue 😢 ) can be found here: https://github.com/igiona/uno-repro-UnitsNetIssue

Workaround

If I remove the XAML binding, or a change the Ratio? into a ìnt?` the Exception is not thrown anymore.

Works on UWP/WinUI

No

Environment

No response

NuGet package version(s)

No response

Affected platforms

Windows (WinAppSDK)

IDE

Visual Studio 2022

IDE version

No response

Relevant plugins

No response

Anything else we need to know?

Since I'm not able to easily repro this issue, I still wonder weather Uno has anything to do with the issue itself.
I hope you can give me some hints in order to proceed with the debugging...

Answer 1 · 2024-06-20T20:40:12.000Z

Can you set this property and take a look at the output? It may show will control has an issue.

Answer 2 · 2024-06-21T09:18:34.000Z

Can you set this property and take a look at the output? It may show will control has an issue.

@jeromelaban I added it in the App ctor:

    public App()
    {
        this.InitializeComponent();
        this.DebugSettings.LayoutCycleTracingLevel = LayoutCycleTracingLevel.High;
    }

I guess since Uno is not present in WinUI the warning can be ignored, but still I don't see any additional log in the Output/Debug tab.

Answer 3 · 2024-06-21T12:08:13.000Z

@igiona You may need to enable native debugging to get this to work.

Answer 4 · 2024-06-21T12:44:29.000Z

enable native debugging

Thanks, it helped!
(for the reader that doesn't know what that is as me: https://stackoverflow.com/a/74238776/7157908)

Now I get the logs, and from what I can see it points to AutoLayout and TextBox.
Not surprisingly because this is the TextBox that in my app causes the crash (https://github.com/igiona/uno-repro-UnitsNetIssue/blob/bc36c61b1e1e0c632430bfdbf894e94230ad2ed2/UnitsNetsIssue/Presentation/MainPage.xaml#L21-L23).
The crashing app NavigationBar.Content looks pretty much the same as the one linked above.

@jeromelaban can you read more out of the logs?

Log

MyApp.Presentation.MainModel: Information: New BSOC BatteryStateOfCharge { Value = 100 % }
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 7. Launching Measure Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infx64.000000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 7","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 7","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 7","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infxinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 7","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 21.600000x34.400002 new: 36.799999x17.600000","LayoutCycleCountdown: 7","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 6. Launching Arrange Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(0.000000,0.000000 926.400024x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F674A90","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(880.000000,0.000000 36.799999x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(36.799999xinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 36.799999x17.600000 new: 21.600000x34.400002","LayoutCycleCountdown: 6","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 5. Launching Measure Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infx64.000000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 5","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 5","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 5","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infxinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 5","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 21.600000x34.400002 new: 36.799999x17.600000","LayoutCycleCountdown: 5","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 4. Launching Arrange Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(0.000000,0.000000 926.400024x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F674A90","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(880.000000,0.000000 36.799999x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(36.799999xinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 36.799999x17.600000 new: 21.600000x34.400002","LayoutCycleCountdown: 4","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 3. Launching Measure Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infx64.000000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 3","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 3","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 3","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infxinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 3","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 21.600000x34.400002 new: 36.799999x17.600000","LayoutCycleCountdown: 3","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 2. Launching Arrange Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(0.000000,0.000000 926.400024x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F674A90","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(880.000000,0.000000 36.799999x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(36.799999xinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 36.799999x17.600000 new: 21.600000x34.400002","LayoutCycleCountdown: 2","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 1. Launching Measure Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infx64.000000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 1","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 1","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 1","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(infxinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 1","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 21.600000x34.400002 new: 36.799999x17.600000","LayoutCycleCountdown: 1","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] Layout Iteration Countdown: 0. Launching Arrange Pass.
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(0.000000,0.000000 926.400024x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F674A90","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Arrange(880.000000,0.000000 36.799999x22.400000)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Uno.Toolkit.UI.AutoLayout","Instance: 0x0000028D2F6777F0","TypeIndex: 702"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(VerticalAlignment=1)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "SetValue(HorizontalAlignment=2)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "Measure(36.799999xinf)","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
[LayoutCycleTracing] "DesiredSize changed, old: 36.799999x17.600000 new: 21.600000x34.400002","LayoutCycleCountdown: 0","ClassName: Microsoft.UI.Xaml.Controls.TextBlock","Instance: 0x0000028D2F75E940","TypeIndex: 616"
Microsoft.ui.xaml.dll!00007FF81F23D4A5: CallContext:[\ImageDecodeActivity] 88000FA8 - AG_E_LAYOUT_CYCLE
Layout Iteration Countdown: 7. Launching Measure Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 6. Launching Arrange Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 5. Launching Measure Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 4. Launching Arrange Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 3. Launching Measure Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 2. Launching Arrange Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 1. Launching Measure Pass.
Layout Iteration Countdown: 0. Launching Arrange Pass.
Exception thrown at 0x00007FF92B23F39C (KernelBase.dll) in MyApp.exe: WinRT originate error - 0x802B0014 : 'Layout cycle detected.  Layout could not complete.'.

Answer 5 · 2024-06-21T13:38:24.000Z

@carldebilly this looks like an autolayout issue, could you take a look?

Answer 6 · 2024-06-21T14:50:52.000Z

@igiona could you provide a screenshot of the net8.0-windows10.xxx node in your project? This seems similar to #1131 (which is fixed in toolkit 6.0.24), and we'd need to know which version of the toolkit your app is using.

Answer 7 · 2024-06-21T14:58:12.000Z

@jeromelaban I guess you mean this?

Can I bump only the toolkit to 6.0.24 or is there already a "Uno.Sdk" 5.2 release I can use?

Answer 8 · 2024-06-21T15:36:45.000Z

Thanks! At this time, there's no uno.sdk which uses that version, we're working on unifying versions so that this upgrade scenario gets easier. In the meantime, you can change the version in your Directory.Build.props file.

Answer 9 · 2024-06-21T20:27:33.000Z

I confirm that with the toolkit version 6.0.24 this issue is fixed 👏

Once again, thank you for the great support!